Maynard Institute archives

“I Forgot Chris Matthews Was White”

by richard0536

Host’s Praise for Obama Provides Teaching Moment

Ray Suarez Does Double Duty in Reporting From Haiti

Anchor Quits to Work as Nurse in Haiti

Yves Colon Helps Produce Creole-Language Broadcasts

Who Was in Haiti Before Columbus Arrived?

3 of 5 Haitian-Americans Lost "Loved Ones" in Quake

TV One Cancels 5 p.m. Rerun of "Washington Watch"

Reggie Bush Cover Turns Off Some Essence Readers

Columnist "Lost It" at Teddy Pendergrass Funeral

Short Takes

In MSNBC’s discussion after President Obama’s State of the Union speech, Chris Matthews said, "I forgot he was black tonight for an hour." He maintains, "One million times I’d say the same thing again and again." (Video)

Host’s Praise for Obama Provides Teaching Moment

Chris Matthews’ admiring comment on MSNBC Wednesday after President Obama’s State of the Union address – "I forgot he was black tonight for an hour" – provided another opportunity for examining racial mindsets, and some instantly rose to the occasion.

For his part, Matthews didn’t see the problem. "I thought I was saying something wonderful and positive about America," the MSNBC host told Adam Howard of theGrio.com.

"One million times I’d say the same thing again and again," he added.

"Matthews implores his critics to take another look at the footage from Wednesday night. He strongly believes that if people listen carefully to the words that he spoke that they will see he was only trying to point out that members of Congress and Americans watching the president’s speech at home ‘saw [Obama] as an individual person and as our leader’ not as part of a racial or ethnic group," Howard wrote.

Jesse Washington, the Associated Press’ reporter on race and ethnicity, wrote on Friday that Matthews’ comment "caused a rapid furor, with many calling the quote a troubling sign that blackness is viewed – perhaps unconsciously – as a handicap that still needs to be overcome.

"Apparently, Matthews forgot to ask black people if they WANT to be de-raced."

Ta-Nehisi Coates, the Atlantic magazine blogger, titled his Thursday morning post, "I Just Remembered Chris Matthews Was White."

"I think it’s most worth noting that ‘I forgot Obama was black’ -in all its iterations – is something that white people should stop saying, if only because it’s really dishonest," Coates said. For good measure, he posted a video of comedian Chris Rock railing about white people complimenting blacks for being well-spoken.

"One way to think about this is to flip the frame," Coates wrote. "Around these parts, we’ve been known, from time to time, to chat about the NFL. We’ve also been known to chat about the intricacies of beer. If you hang around you’ll notice that there are no shortage of women in these discussions. Having read a particularly smart take on Brett Favre, or having received a good recommendations on a particular IPA, it would not be a compliment for me to say, ‘Wow, I forgot you were a woman.’" Indeed, it would be pretty offensive.

"The problems is three-fold. First, it takes my necessarily limited, and necessarily blinkered, experience with the fairer sex and builds it into a shibboleth of invented truth. Then it takes that invented truth as a fair standard by which I can measure one’s ‘woman-ness.’ So if football and beer don’t fit into my standard, I stop seeing the person as a woman. Finally instead of admitting that my invented truth is the problem, I put the onus on the woman. Hence the claim ‘I forgot you were a woman,’ as opposed to ‘I just realized my invented truth was wrong.’

" . . . In fact, Chris Matthews didn’t forget Barack Obama was black. Chris Matthews forgot that Chris Matthews was white."

On National Public Radio’s "Tell Me More," the subject came up in the weekly "barbershop" segment. Host Michel Martin made the same point that Washington did in his AP story.

"We’ve talked about the whole Harry Reid thing and Harry Reid saying that he has no Negro dialect except if he wants to, and I was thinking, okay, it’s annoying, but why exactly?

"The reason I’m thinking about this, it still implies that being black, there’s something wrong with it that you have to forget about. For example, nobody would say, you know, the late great Tim Russert, nobody would say: I forgot he was from Buffalo. I don’t even see that he’s from Buffalo.

"He loved Buffalo, and he’d talk about it all the time, and was that anything – was there anything wrong with that? No, and so for people to constantly say, well, I don’t even notice your race, is there something wrong with it? I actually think I’m a very nice toasty brown, and I have no problem with it. And I don’t understand why this is something we have constantly sort of apologize for and look beyond."

Meanwhile, Obama’s State of the Union speech proved to be one of the most-watched, according to Nielsen ratings. But there was dissatisfaction that Obama’s emphasis on jobs meant that other topics – such as foreign policy or immigration – got what some considered insufficient mention.

Ray Suarez tells viewers of the Hispanic Information and Telecommunications Network that Haitians are proving to be patient and adept at doing for themselves. (Video)

Ray Suarez Does Double Duty in Reporting From Haiti

"A lot of the reporting that I heard in mainstream press that I saw before I got down here seemed like it was looking for commotion, looking for violence, looking for things that weren’t going well," Ray Suarez reported this week from Port-au-Prince, Haiti.

"But in the several days that we’ve been here and traveling throughout the capital, I gotta tell you. The remarkable thing is how little of that there is."

Suarez is in Haiti for his regular gig as senior correspondent for PBS’ "The NewsHour," but this report was for "Destination Casa Blanca," a weekly news show he hosts for the Hispanic Information and Telecommunications Network.

"Haitians waiting patiently at factory gates for the places where they worked to open," he continued, "to stream in in the thousands, including thousands of people who are now homeless, and yet were clean, well-pressed, dressed for work, and ID card in hand, and ready to start earning a living again. Remember, hardly any wages have been earned in this place for more than two weeks now. . . . You know it’s remarkable how people who give up on government coming to their rescue . . . often find ways to do things for themselves."

"With the blessing of the Newshour. I do the show, for HITN, on my own time," Suarez told Journal-isms by e-mail from Haiti. "It’s fun, and helps me pay two whopping big college tuitions."

Anchor Quits to Work as Nurse in Haiti

Julie Pearce"The pictures and stories that continue to pour out of Haiti show a nation that will take months and even years to rebuild. For the Northland’s NewsCenter weekend anchor Julie Pearce, who has spent the last four years of her life telling stories, those pictures were enough to make a life changing decision," Boua Xiong reported Thursday for KBJR-TV in Duluth, Minn.

" ‘I’d sit there and produce the show and read the headlines and you know download the stories and sit there and read the headlines to the audience and it just broke my heart knowing that there’s something that I can actually do, that I actually have the skills to do something about what I’m reading and what I’m telling to our audience,’ Pearce said.

"Pearce became a registered nurse last summer after graduating from St. Scholastica. Earlier this week she got the green light to join the Evangelical Free Church of America Touch Global Crisis Response team.

". . . Pearce’s last show will be on Sunday."

In this Jan. 22 video, Internews producer Frederick Alexis and Internews journalist Johnny Etienne talk about the destruction of a local radio station and their plans to help get information to Haitians. (Video)

Yves Colon Helps Produce Creole-Language Broadcasts

Shortly after the Jan. 12 earthquake hit, we reported that Yves Colon, a Haitian-born journalism lecturer at the University of Miami, took this coming semester off work so he could go back to Haiti and help rebuild the country’s media sector with Internews, a not-for-profit organization.

Internews has since reported that local radio stations in Haiti have begun airing a Creole-language humanitarian information broadcast produced by Internews, reported by local journalists "with support from Internews team member Yves Colon, a Haitian journalist with more than 20 years of experience.

"The program, Nouvelles-Utiles (News You Can Use) will be produced daily and distributed to local radio stations, which are eager to air it."

A Jan 21 program "included stories refuting rumors that there was an imposed curfew in Port-au-Prince, and notice of water distribution locations, bank re-openings, and waste management services. Information from the Red Cross discouraged hasty and uncoordinated disposal of bodies, and dispelled rumors that dead bodies cause disease.

"Internews staff in Haiti produced the program and distributed it on CD to 11 stations. More stations will be added as they return to broadcasting."

Who Was in Haiti Before Columbus Arrived?

Some news reports have begun to discuss Haiti’s rich history as the first nation ever established by slaves who liberated themselves, but few have reported on what Haiti was like before the colonizers arrived and imported slaves.

Doug George-Kanentiio graphically described what some might call "ethnic cleansing" in a piece Friday for indianz.com. It began, "Haiti is a place of angry spirits never released from the agony of their passing.

"This land was called Ayiti by its Arawak-Taino native peoples who may, according to some, be the relatives of the Iroquois," wrote George-Kanentiio, a Mohawk.

"So what did Colon and the Spaniards do to this paradise inhabited by Arawak-Tainos who may have numbered as many as three million on that island alone?" George-Kanentiio continued, referring to Christopher Columbus, whom he said should more accurately be called Cristobal Colon.

". . . The Native population collapsed before this savagery which the Spaniards, and their European imitators, would repeat throughout the Caribbean, in Mexico and into Central and South America. Of the millions of Natives who had made Ayita into an ecological Eden only 60,000 survived to 1507. By 1531 only 600 Arawak-Taino were alive and a few years later none at all. Complete genocide by intent and design. Nothing remains of those people other than a weak DNA trail."

3 of 5 Haitian-Americans Lost "Loved Ones" in Quake

"Haitians living in the United States are deeply impacted by the devastating earthquake that hit their island homeland earlier this month, according to a poll sponsored by New America Media," Andrew Lam reported Thursday for New America Media.

"A shocking three out of five respondents said they had lost some of their ‘loved ones.’ Two-thirds felt the situation in their country was so dire they were willing to move back to Haiti for a period of time to help with the reconstruction.

". . . Additionally, 62 percent indicated that they were willing to adopt or foster a Haitian orphan from the earthquake. Three-fifths felt that the United States should welcome at least 50,000 new Haitian refugees to alleviate the calamity in the island nation."

TV One Cancels 5 p.m. Rerun of "Washington Watch"

If you’re looking for the 5 p.m. repeat of Sunday’s "Washington Watch" political talk show on TV One, expect to see reruns of the "Martin" sitcom instead. The repeat has been moved to the early-morning hours.

"Washington Watch has always been intended to be a Sunday morning show, but when it was new in the fall Johnathan wanted to offer an additional afternoon sampling opportunity for the show, which TV One did until the beginning of the year," spokeswoman Lynn McReynolds told Journal-isms, referring to TV One CEO Johnathan Rodgers.

The show, oriented toward African American interests and hosted by Roland Martin, airs at 11 a.m. Eastern  time and now repeats at 2 a.m. Eastern and 6 a.m. Eastern the next morning.

A spokeswoman for the Nielsen Co. told Journal-isms in October that "Washington Watch" was carving a small niche at 11 a.m. but that the 5 p.m. rerun barely registered in its ratings.

Reggie Bush Cover Turns Off Some Essence Readers

Essence's February cover"A high-profile black athlete with a white girlfriend?" Jenice Armstrong began Wednesday in her Philadelphia Daily News column.

"No big thing.

"Well, not unless the athlete happens to be on the cover of Essence magazine and that particular issue is supposed to be all about ‘black men, love and relationships.’

"Then, what you have is a potentially sticky situation especially since the cover model is none other than New Orleans Saints player Reggie Bush, who is romantically involved with Kim Kardashian. Besides her reality-TV show ‘Keeping Up with the Kardashians,’ Kardashian’s biggest claim to fame is a pornographic sex tape she made with former boyfriend Ray J, brother of singer Brandy.

". . . The image of Bush has irritated a long-frayed nerve that is further aggravated by the fact that Essence, a magazine many black women think of as their own, made him its cover image. It’s stirred up an old debate about high-profile black men and their preference for dating white or light-skinned women.

". . . on Essence.com, a lively debate is waging with more than 1,300 comments posted on this issue." (The comments page has apparently been deleted.)

"Essence declines comment," spokeswoman Dana Baxter told Journal-isms.

Some readers noted that the cover photo apparently was used in GQ in 2006.

Columnist "Lost It" at Teddy Pendergrass Funeral

Teddy Pendergrass "The music swelled, and the familiar opening chords of Teddy Pendergrass‘ sweet, sweet ballad, ‘You’re My Latest, My Greatest Inspiration,’ rose to the rafters of Enon Tabernacle Baptist Church," Annette John-Hall wrote Sunday in the Philadelphia Inquirer.

"I said I wasn’t going to cry. After all, I was there to cover the funeral of Pendergrass ‚Äî who died Jan. 13 at 59 ‚Äî not to mourn him. But when actor and R&B crooner Tyrese Gibson took the mic, sounding so much like Pendergrass, and clearly in pain over the death of the man he is slated to portray in a film, well, I lost it right there."

Pendergrass’ death took Barry Saunders, columnist for the News & Observer in Raleigh, N.C., back 30 years to his days as an obituary writer at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

"There was a beautiful female reporter whose racial heritage some of us in the newsroom spent way too many hours trying to guess," he told readers.

"Was she white? Was she a sista?

"We were too polite to ask, and the answer would’ve remained a mystery had not I ‚Äî unintentionally ‚Äî cracked the code.

"’Yo, Slim,’ I asked her one day when she passed by the obit desk, ‘You going to the ‘Teddy’ concert tonight?’

"She looked at me blankly before answering two questions at once: ‘Teddy who?’

"She definitely wasn’t a sista, since in those days every black woman over the age of consent knew there was only one Teddy, soul singer Teddy Pendergrass."

Saunders also recalled that he had more recently seen a guy asleep at a concert by Maxwell, a current-day heartthrob.

"I never saw a man sleeping through a Teddy concert. If anything, fellas were taking notes — if they were permitted in at all," Saunders wrote.

Short Takes

  • Asked for advice to give news organizations on his last day at the Poynter Institute, Keith Woods, its No. 2 administrator, said, "If your primary mission is to have an informed public so that they can make the best decisions, then your first responsibility is to be sure that whoever is watching/reading/listening/clicking is getting the most complete story about themselves and everybody else." Woods, who is leaving to become vice president of diversity in news and operations at National Public Radio, also said, "There is a cruel irony that often reveals itself as organizations position themselves as champions of the forgotten and downtrodden. The picture we paint tends to be a one-dimensional portrait of people who are only forgotten and downtrodden and in need of help. We miss their ordinariness. They become frozen in permanent pathology. We miss the normal parts of their lives that make them laugh, love, cry, rejoice."
  • "Television viewers in the United States seeking international news are starting to switch over to foreign channels to learn what is happening in the outside world, media watchers here say," Haider Rizvi wrote from New York for Inter-Press Service. "’They are comparable to CNN,’ said Steve Randall, about television news channels such as Russia Today, Al Jazeera, CCTV of China, and the Press TV of Iran, which are now being watched by millions of people in the United States via cable and dish networks."
  • Anita Malik"When we spoke with East West founder and editor-in-chief Anita Malik last year, she seemed excited about the prospect of relaunching her pan-Asian American magazine after a nearly two-year hiatus," Amanda Ernst wrote Friday for MediaBistro. "But now, five months later, Malik is telling a new story. In a series of posts on her blog, Glossy On The Outside, Malik has revealed that she is seriously questioning whether there is a future for East West."
  • "Dawn Hasbrouck, a weekend anchor and reporter at Boston’s WBZ-TV, has been named Patrick Elwood’s new co-anchor on WFLD-Ch. 32’s ‘Fox Chicago News at Noon,’ replacing Nancy Loo, effective the week of Feb. 15," Phil Rosenthal reported Wednesday for the Chicago Tribune.
  • "The New York Times refuses to confirm or deny a report that its Jerusalem bureau chief, Ethan Bronner, has a child who is an enlisted member of the Israeli Defense Force¬†‚Äî even though such a relationship would pose a serious conflict of interest," Fairness & Accuracy In Media reported Wednesday. It quoted a response from Times Foreign Editor Susan Chira: "Mr. Bronner’s son is a young adult who makes his own decisions. At the Times, we have found Mr. Bronner’s coverage to be scrupulously fair and we are confident that will continue to be the case."
  • "Upon his return from a trip to earthquake ravaged Haiti, civil rights advocate and Push Coalition president, Jesse L. Jackson came to Charlotte, N.C. to talk about economic reciprocity for African American businesses and communities," Afrique Kilimanjaro reported Wednesday for the Carolina Pacemaker. "Jackson spoke to members of the National Newspaper Publishers Association (NNPA) at the association‚Äôs winter conference held last week in the Queen City."
  • Native American high school students planning to attend college and curious about media careers will learn firsthand about higher education opportunities and journalism during a week-long workshop this April 19-23 at Crazy Horse Memorial in South Dakota‚Äôs Black Hills, the Freedom Forum announced on Wednesday. Students interested in attending the workshop, or schools interested in nominating students, should contact Janine Harris at 605-677-5424 or jharris (at) freedomforum.org by Feb. 26 for application information.
  • James Rucker, executive director of the media activist group Color of Change, praised journalist-of-color groups, among others, for supporting measures to endorse net neutrality, "the principle that prevents Internet Service Providers from controlling what kind of content or applications you can access online. Rucker wrote Thursday in the Huffington Post that he was "troubled that a number of our nation’s leading civil rights groups had also taken positions questioning or against Net Neutrality, using arguments that were in step with those of the big phone and cable companies like AT&T and Comcast, which are determined to water down any new FCC rules."
  • Donnie Simpson"Donnie Simpson brought his 32-year career as a morning radio personality in Washington to an emotional close Friday, signing off with a parade of celebrity well wishers and tears from his staff and colleagues," Paul Farhi reported in the Washington Post. "His four-hour show on WPGC-FM (95.5) spilled over an extra two hours to accommodate the phoned-in farewells from Stevie Wonder, Smokey Robinson, Wyclef Jean and other musicians whom Simpson has championed during his decades on the radio and as host of Black Entertainment Television’s ‘Video Soul.’ " Others who called in included Tavis Smiley, Bootsy Collins, Frankie Beverly, John Legend and D.L. Hughley, according to the Dave Hughes Web site dcrtv.com.

Follow Richard Prince on Twitter

Facebook users: Sign up for the "Richard Prince’s Journal-isms" fan page.

 

Related posts

Departing Editor Wins Over Community Critic

richard

Making Sense of Taylor’s Death — or Not

richard

Anna Nicole Takes Up the Bandwidth

richard

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.