Maynard Institute archives

Supreme Court, Black Columnists Agree

by richard0446

Writers Have Long Questioned Sentencing Disparities

The Supreme Court’s Monday decision that judges may impose lighter sentences for crack cocaine placed the conservative jurists in what could be rare agreement with the bulk of African American columnists, many of whom have long raised questions about a disparity that the Boston Globe’s Derrick Z. Jackson wrote “has come to symbolize racial injustice in criminal justice.”

“In the crack case, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said it was reasonable for a federal judge in Virginia to impose a lower sentence than one prescribed by the guidelines because of his disagreement with the rule that imposed the same sentence for a crack dealer as for someone selling 100 times as much powder cocaine,” Robert Barnes wrote on the Washington Post Web site. “The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit said the law did not allow the judge to make such a determination.

“But Ginsburg wrote that ‘the cocaine guidelines, like all other guidelines, are advisory only’ and that the ‘the court of appeals erred in holding the crack/powder disparity effectively mandatory.’

“The disparity has been challenged by civil rights groups because crack is most often used by African Americans, powder cocaine by whites, thus subjecting blacks to the tougher penalties. The court’s decision did not touch on that argument.”

When the Trotter Group of African American columnists met with President Bill Clinton on Nov. 1, 1995, the first question was, “Why did you reject the Federal Sentencing Commission recommendation, and also the opinion of our own attorney general, that sentencing . . . for possession of crack and powder cocaine ought to be equalized?”

Clinton replied that the legislation implementing that recommendation would also have lowered penalties for money laundering, which he opposed, and said that instead of reducing the penalties for crack, “I think they should raise the penalty for trafficking in cocaine.”

“Miffed somewhat by his answers, the columnists nonetheless went away with warm feelings about Clinton,” Newsday columnist Les Payne wrote then.

When Clinton’s wife, Hillary Rodham Clinton, met with the Trotter Group in August at the National Association of Black Journalists convention in Las Vegas, it was again the first question on the table. Did she think her husband was mistaken? “I agree . . . that it was a Hobson’s choice” he was faced with, she said, adding that she was on record that the disparities should be eliminated. However, she said, “As a matter of practical politics, you might not be able to get from where we are, from 100-to-1, to parity. But we should ought to be able to get to 10-to-1 or something that would move us in the right direction.”

The next day, Jackson posed the question to a second Democratic presidential candidate, Sen. Barack Obama. “Yes, it was a mistake,” Obama said of Bill Clinton’s signing a bill that kept in place the disparate sentences. However, he added, it still is a problem that “our young men are in a situation where they believe the only recourse for them is the drug trade. So there is a balancing act that has to be done in terms of, do we want to spend all our political capital on a very difficult issue that doesn’t get at some of the underlying issues; whether we want to spend more of that political capital getting early childhood education in place, getting after-school programs in place, getting summer school programs in place.”

[In a conference call with black journalists on Tuesday, Obama said he was pleased with the Supreme Court ruling, calling it “a step in the right direction.” However, he said he would have to see the language of the new sentencing guidelines and would be examining whether they could or should apply to those already serving time. Later in the day, the U.S. Sentencing Commission voted to retroactively reduce the penalties for using and selling crack cocaine, making more than 2,500 federal inmates eligible for early release starting in March.]

Writing Nov. 23 in the Record of Hackensack, N.J., Lawrence Aaron noted that “Federal reforms under consideration could potentially reduce sentences for thousands convicted of crack sales and possession. If applied retroactively, 19,500 prisoners would get their sentences cut. The proposals lower the longest sentences by about a year.

“An advocacy group promoting prison reform estimates that African-American prisoners are 85 percent of those who would benefit from lowering federal crack sentences retroactively.”

Dissenting on Monday were Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr.

To some commentators who pressed hard on the sentencing disparity issue, supporters of those justices have some explaining to do.

DeWayne Wickham of USA Today, a member of the Trotter Group, noted in a column to be published Tuesday that John Payton, named last week to the top job of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, “the advocacy group that has spearheaded the civil rights movements’ legal challenges to racial bias and discrimination for more than half a century,” had testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee in support of the “well-qualified” rating the American Bar Association gave Alito.

However, the Legal Defense Fund had concluded that Alito “would cause a substantial shift in the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence on civil rights and that his confirmation would be to the detriment of the nation.”

Payton’s defenders said he was carrying out the wishes of the ABA. While Wickham said he would give Payton the benefit of the doubt, he added, “Civil rights litigation is not the work of those who seek a Faustian bargain.”

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

NBC Drew 74,000 More Black Women During Series

The “African-American Women: Where They Stand” series that aired on “NBC Nightly News” from Nov. 26 to Nov. 30 delivered 74,000 more black viewers than usual, and 70,000 of them were women, an NBC spokeswoman told Journal-isms on Monday.

 

 

The five-part series was the subject of an extensive e-mailing and word-of-mouth campaign among African American women.

NBC reached 863,000 African American viewers, which was up 9 percent, or 74,000, from the season-to-date average of 789,000, spokeswoman Lauren Kapp said, quoting Nielsen figures.

Among African American women, NBC reached 535,000 viewers, up 15 percent, or 70,000, from the season-to-date average of 465,000.

Among African American women aged 25 to 54, the network reached 191,000 viewers, up 12 percent, or 21,000, from the season-to-date average of 170,000.

NBC won the November “sweeps,” which ended on Wednesday of that week, but came in second to ABC’s “World News” for the week of the series.

Writing about the series for AdAge.com on the Wednesday of that week, Carol Watson said, “The journalists covering the stories are incredibly talented black women that I am sure had to fight hard to get even these 2-minute segments running for five consecutive days. But the debate on the value and context of the information still creates a storm among black consumers. Blacks continue to demand a positive and solutions-oriented point of view from media.

“For many black women, the complaint about the news series is the constant burden of the negatives with little or no solution or context for the reasons for the disparities. The Monday segment compared black women to white women and . . . black women to black men — a pattern in news media that makes the black consumer cautious and hesitant about the motivations of the media. As Essence Editor Angela Burt-Murray said in an online comment, that segment may make a black woman want to shoot herself in the head.

“Thankfully, the online interviews provide far more context and information than the two-minute segments.”

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

GOP Hopefuls Soften Stances in Univision Debate

 

 

“Facing a Spanish-speaking national audience for the first time, the Republican presidential candidates soft-pedaled their hard-line stances on immigration and sidestepped questions about the estimated 12 million undocumented workers already living in the United States,” Beth Reinhard and Laura Figueroa reported Monday in the Miami Herald.

“. . . Sunday’s debate, and a similar forum with the Democratic candidates in September, made history as the first presidential debates on Spanish-language television. The questions were asked in Spanish by Univisión anchors Maria Elena Salinas and Jorge Ramos — household names in the Hispanic community — and simultaneously translated into English for the candidates.

“Coming just 25 days before the first votes are cast in Iowa on Jan. 3, the debate was expected to draw a larger average audience than the 2.2 million who watched the Democratic debate.”

Jim Kuhnhenn of the Associated Press added: “Initially scheduled for September, the debate had to be rescheduled because only Sen. John McCain had agreed to appear on the earlier date. This time, the only candidate who refused to attend was Tom Tancredo, a long-shot candidate who has made a tough immigration stance the centerpiece of his campaign.

“Atonement may have been a factor in their participation. In September, Giuliani, Thompson, McCain and Romney were roundly criticized for failing to attend a debate devoted to minority issues at historically black Morgan State University in Baltimore.” The references were to former New York mayor Rudolph Giuliani, former Sen. Fred Thompson and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney.

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

Columnist Has No Patience for Mormon “Bigotry”

 

“Whenever a proselytizing Mormon knocks on my Harlem door, I chase him away as brusquely as I would chase away a Klansman, or an evangelical Christian Republican, and for much the same reason,” Les Payne wrote on Sunday in Newsday.

“I have zero tolerance for racial intolerance.

“Mormon Mitt Romney took pains to assure evangelical Republicans Thursday that they would have nothing to fear should he be elected president.

“. . . I rather suspect, however, that white evangelicals have little to fear from Romney. It is not so clear for the rest of us, especially those the Mormons libel as bearing ‘the curse of Cain,’ who killed his Biblical brother Abel. I refer, of course, to Brigham Young’s interpreted Mormon doctrine that ‘the Lord’ cursed Cain’s descendants with ‘a flat nose and dark skin.’ Many old-line church apostles still consider blacks as inferiors.

“Such segregation differs from other religions mainly in that the Mormon nonsense is homegrown, allegedly ‘revealed’ in upstate New York and transported to Utah. Not until 1978 did the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints allow black men to enter the priesthood. This revised ‘revelation’ from the heavens came amid growing protests from African-Americans as college sports teams refused to compete against Brigham Young and other church colleges.

“What exactly is the shelf life of God-inspired bigotry? Mitt Romney grew into adulthood under a Mormon doctrine instructing members that Negroes could not enter heaven or the priesthood because they were cursed by God, and inferior. Laying aside the Mormon hocus-pocus, Romney is no different in such racial conditioning than his comparable, evangelical white Christian, to say nothing of the secular crowd.”

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

Oprah Stumps for Obama; Media Weigh Effect

“Oprah Winfrey may be just what Barack Obama needs to push him over the top in South Carolina,” Chicago Sun-Times columnist Mary Mitchell wrote Sunday from Columbia, S.C.

“People along the black beauty and barbershop belt appear to trust the Queen of Talk a lot more than they trust the politicians. Obama’s aggressive campaign targeting this treasure trove of black voters apparently has helped get him within two percentage points of Hillary Clinton, according to a recent poll released by the Obama campaign.

“The latest Rasmussen Poll shows that Obama was the top choice of 34 percent of the state’s likely voters —two points shy of Hillary Clinton’s 36 percent. A month ago, Clinton had a 10-percentage-point lead. Obviously, Oprah’s influence isn’t being underestimated. Former President Bill Clinton added Charleston, S.C., to his schedule and promoted his wife’s health care plan there Saturday.”

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

 

 

World Opinion Split on Importance of Press Freedom

“World opinion is divided on the importance of press freedom, according to a BBC World Service poll of 11,344 people across 14 countries,” the BBC announced on Monday.

“While an average of 56% across all countries think that freedom of the press is very important to ensure a free society, 40% believe that social harmony and peace are more important, even if it means controlling what is reported for the greater good.

“56% of people in the 14 countries polled think the press and media in their country is free to report the news accurately without bias. Only 19% say there is little or no media freedom in their country.

“Of the countries where press freedom is most highly valued, Western developed countries are more critical of how honestly and accurately the news is reported, including Germany (28% average rating for good performance of public and private media), Great Britain (29%), and the USA (29%) whereas Venezuela (44%), South Africa (49%), Nigeria (58%), and Kenya (61%) rate the media performance more positively.

“In countries where social stability is more highly valued, those surveyed in India (61% good performance) and the UAE (52%) believe the news is being reported honestly, contrasting with a more negative view of press performance in Russia (27%), Mexico (28%), Brazil (31%) and Singapore (37%).” The reference is to the United Arab Emirates.

Meanwhile, “Sketching Human Rights,” a collection of thought-provoking cartoons from leading international cartoonists illustrating the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, opened Monday, Human Rights Day, at the United Nations. The exhibition is to travel to locations around the world throughout 2008, as Editor & Publisher noted.

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

Latina Magazine Shoots for High-End Advertisers

With the March issue, Latina magazine will shed its service-heavy tone for a more aspirational one, Lucia Moses reported on Monday for MediaWeek.

“Fashion and beauty will move up in the book and double in pages, while entertainment and food content will shrink. The style pages, now featuring moderately priced items, will start to showcase luxury pieces.”

To carry out the makeover, Mimi Valdés Ryan, who became editorial director at Latina and its brand extensions in November, “tapped fellow former Vibe staffers Florian Bachleda and George Pitts as creative director and photography director, respectively. They worked together at the hip-hop title, where Valdés Ryan was editor until July 2006,” Moses said.

The magazine hopes the editorial shift will help Latina grow its share of spending by cosmetics companies and give it entrée to high-end fashion advertisers, Moses wrote.

MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.

Short Takes

  • “An Iraqi investigating magistrate on Sunday convened the first criminal hearing in the case of Associated Press photographer Bilal Hussein, who has been held by the U.S. military without charges for nearly 20 months,” Kim Gamel reported for the Associated Press. However, Magistrate Dhia al-Kinani issued an order that the proceedings and details of the material presented remain secret.
  • “Gunmen shot a crime reporter 45 times in a Mexican town plagued by drug violence on Saturday after a high-speed chase as he tried to escape on his motorcycle,” Reuters reported Saturday from Mexico City. “Cut off by a vehicle in Uruapan, in the state of Michoacan, Gerardo Garcia fled on his motorcycle as far as his home, where his pursuers killed him, police and a source at the newspaper where he worked told Reuters.”

 

 

 
  • Jeanette Brown, director of the library at USA Today, is one of the 43 employees taking a buyout at the McLean, Va.-based national newspaper, Brown told Journal-isms on Monday. She has been with the Gannett Co. for 27 years and is a 1992 graduate of the Maynard Institute’s management program. Brown said the library staff of 13 will shrink to eight when she and five others who took the buyout, including African Americans Ray Hicks and Lisa Washington, depart. Among others of color who confirmed they took the offer is Andre Montgomery, senior administrator, or office manager, of the sports department. As reported Saturday, four black sports journalists are leaving.
  • “May I provide some clarity to the noise that crackled across the airwaves and digital space all day following the sentencing of Michael Vick to 23 months in prison on charges stemming from his involvement in the well-chronicled dog-fighting mess?” sports journalist Roy S. Johnson wrote late Monday on his blog. Hear “me on this: Michael Vick got what he deserved. He messed up (that change of language is for the little children who may stumble upon this post) — or made a severe “error in judgment,” as his able attorney, Billy Martin, so aptly stated today —and now must pay his debt.”
  • Two fewer Americans are affiliated with the Bahamas newspaper the Nassau Guardian. Leon Dash, the longtime Washington Post reporter who is Swanlund Chair professor at the University of Illinois, resigned from the board on Saturday, and Alison Bethel, who came to the paper in March after having been Detroit News Washington Bureau chief and then executive editor of the Washington-based weekly Legal Times, its No. 2 job, is gone after serving as managing editor, the paper’s highest editorial job. “It became clear that the Colina Group owners were not interested in the Board having any input in the running of The Guardian,” Dash told Journal-isms. Bethel, who was in Washington over the weekend, said she was not free to discuss what had transpired.
  • “The House Judiciary Committee scheduled a hearing Wednesday (Dec. 12) at 2 p.m. on media consolidation and former CBS anchor Dan Rather is leading the witness list,” John Eggerton reported Monday in Broadcasting & Cable. “The hearing will focus on the impact of media consolidation on localism and diversity. The list includes Rather, now anchor and managing editor of ‘Dan Rather Reports’ on HDNet; Adam Thierer from the Center for Digital Media Freedom, Progress and Freedom Foundation; radio talk-how host Joe Madison; Carol Jenkins of the Women’s Media Center; David Honig, executive director of the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council; and S. Derek Turner, head of research for Free Press.”
  • “According to Arbitron’s ‘special tabulation’ of New York Portable People Meter data, the number of PPMs reporting exposure to Citadel’s WABC/New York on the morning of Don Imus‘ debut was up 87 percent over the average for the previous 10 Mondays,” RadioInk reported on Monday.

 
  • New York Post reporter Leonardo Blair gave readers an account of being stopped and frisked by two cops, “amid a disturbing upswing in complaints lodged against the NYPD,” the Post said. The Dec. 2 story read, in part, “‘Now I understand what black people mean in this country when they talk about things like this,’ I said to Officer Reynolds. ‘What do you mean? I am black, too,’ he said. ‘That’s what makes it so shameful,’ I said. ‘You stood there and watched him cuff me for no reason and you said nothing.’ He walked away.” Blair appeared on National Public Radio’s “Tell Me More” Dec. 4 with New York Daily News columnist Stanley Crouch to discuss the implications of “stop and frisk” police tactics.
  • “The Houston Association of Black Journalists assembled a prominent group of panelists and an eager audience at Rice University to address two questions: Is there a different standard for covering the Black community in the media? Is the media fair when covering Blacks?” Jesse Muhammad reported Sunday in the Final Call.
  • Andre Brooks has been named the new 5 a.m. morning show producer at WRC-TV in Washington, arriving from WAVY-TV, an NBC affiliate in Norfolk, Va. Brooks is returning to his hometown. His parents are Rodney Brooks, deputy managing editor/Money at USA Today, and Sheila Brooks, president of SRB Productions Inc.
  • “After Tropical Storm Noel tore through the Dominican Republic, many New Yorkers have contributed to the relief effort,” the New York Daily News reported on Monday. “Starting tonight at 11, New York 1 News’ Dean Meminger and NY1 Noticias’ Luz Plasencia kick off a five-part series tracking how the relief was distributed. “‘Many people in New York were unaware of the damage caused by Tropical Storm Noel, almost as though the storm was invisible to the outside world,’ Meminger said in a statement. ‘Yet Noel had a major impact on the Dominican economy and a majority of the country’s agriculture was destroyed in an area already struggling.'”
  • “A large flag showing the Olympic rings transformed into handcuffs was unfurled outside the Liaison Office of the central people’s government of China in Hong Kong today by five Reporters Without Borders representatives, including secretary-general Robert Ménard, in a protest to mark Human Rights Day. Two days before,” the organization reported on Monday, “Chinese authorities refused to give visas to members of the press freedom organisation.”
  • “As the new dean of journalism at the University of Nevada-Reno, former San Jose Mercury News top executive Jerry Ceppos hopes to focus many of the school’s faculty and students on the rich environmental and legal reporting topics in the Lake Tahoe area,” Sean Webby wrote in the San Jose (Calif.) Mercury News on Sunday. “But the incoming head of 500-student Donald W. Reynolds School of Journalism and Advanced Media Studies also wants the next generation of journalists to sharpen their analytical skills on a broader issue: ‘How did the media end up in this mess?'” Ceppos succeeds Cole Campbell, who died in a January car accident.

Related posts

Swanston to Be Unity’s Interim Executive Director

richard

NPR Pledges More Diversity on Top Shows

richard

Speaking of Sexism

richard

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.