Maynard Institute archives

Is Artwork Inspiring or Degrading?

by richard0355

Reaction to Illustration "Stunning in Its Ferocity"

'It's been said that this is not a race about race, but of course it is,' the artist wrote. (Credit: Andrea Levy/Plain Dealer)A "visual op-ed" in the Cleveland Plain Dealer was "a thoughtful, fascinating piece of work by one of the most thoughtful, fascinating people who work here," artist Andrea Levy, Ted Diadiun, public editor at the Plain Dealer, wrote on Sunday.

But "the reaction we got from a distressing number of readers was stunning in its ferocity.

"The words were spare: Across the top she said, ‘There is a bridge to somewhere, but can we cross it?’ Below, she continued, ‘or instead, prop-politics? Paperdollitics? The voting booth is a very private place. It’s been said that this is not a race about race, but of course it is. And it’s about our bodies, our partners, the earth and our faiths [plural], as well. Or are these just props, too? Is the flag an accessory?’

"Clearly, to me at least, the illustration emphasized the importance of Obama’s presidential candidacy as an emblematic separation from a time when black men were lynched for being ‘uppity.’

"I spent a lot of time Sunday morning with Levy’s thoughts and imagery, and felt enriched. Many readers shared my appreciation and described the piece as brilliant, inspiring, poetic and eloquent.

"But others — mostly from my side of the political aisle – concluded that Levy meant to imply that anyone who opposes Obama is a racist, and that the noose was there to incite hatred. People called it deplorable, degrading, offensive, disgusting. Some canceled subscriptions and others threatened cancellation unless the paper apologized."

Obama Says Voters Won’t Reject Him Based on Race

"Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) is pointing to the success of his presidential campaign as a sign that voters won’t reject him based on race," Mike Allen wrote¬†Saturday for politico.com.

"’The fact of the matter is people have been continually looking for how race will impact this campaign,’ Obama said in a satellite interview Friday with Washington’s WJLA ABC 7. ‘And yet, I’m here, 30 days out, competitive in Virginia.’"

Meanwhile, Douglass K. Daniel, in an analysis for the Associated Press, wrote¬†on Sunday of a "racially tinged subtext" in vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin’s claim that¬†Obama is "palling around with terrorists" and doesn’t see the United States like other Americans.

And in the New York Times, columnist Nicholas D. Kristof, writing¬†about last month’s survey by the Associated Press, Yahoo and Stanford University on race and the election, said "racists" aren’t the issue.

"Rather, most of the votes that Mr. Obama actually loses belong to well-meaning whites who believe in racial equality and have no objection to electing a black person as president – yet who discriminate unconsciously," Kristof wrote.

He quoted John Dovidio, a psychologist at Yale University: Those voters’ doubts "tend to be attributed not to the person’s race – because that would be racism – but deflected to other areas that can be talked about, such as lack of experience."

New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson addressed the National Association of Latino Elected Officials as a presidential candidate. Though Latino, he failed to attract Hispanic voters during the Democratic primaries, the PBS documentary notes. (Credit: Claudio Rocha)

PBS Film Looks at Latino Influence in Presidential Race

PBS is debuting a primer Wednesday that traces Latino influence in presidential politics from John F. Kennedy to the present.

Among the more intriguing parts of the one-hour documentary "Latinos ’08" is an examination of Latino ambivalance toward Sen. Barack Obama, the Democratic nominee, and the disappointment of many with Sen. John McCain, the head of the Republican ticket and a former¬†champion of immigration reform.

Obama’s message of hope fell flat with Latinos because they¬†are already "replete with aspiration,"¬†Roberto Suro, the former Washington Post and New York Times journalist and founding director of the Pew Hispanic Center, says in the film. For white liberals, voting for Obama is "a way of cleaning their conscience," Rodolfo De La Garza of Columbia University says,¬†asserting that Mexican-Americans have no similar guilt over treatment of African Americans.

Among Obama’s negatives, the senator voted for a wall along the Mexico-U.S. border and had built no relationship with Latino elected officials, Suro said.

His Democratic primary rival, Sen. Hillary Clinton, by contrast, scored numbers among Latinas that exceeded even those among white women, Bill Clinton’s Housing and Urban Development secretary, Henry Cisneros, notes. Ruben Navarrette Jr., syndicated columnist for the San Diego Union-Tribune, says, "She learned from the mistakes of her husband, who presided over eight years of a black and white America."¬†

On the Republican side, analysts in the film note that McCain now says he would not vote for his own immigration reform bill, disappointing Latinos who had heavily supported him in his Senate campaigns in Arizona. Meanwhile, other Republicans, such as Rep. Tom Tancredo, R-Colo., have been outspoken in their opposition to illegal immigration, a stand that spilled over into antagonism toward Hispanics in general.

In the film, the Rev. Luis Cort?©s Jr., president of Esperanza USA, a network of Latino churches, notes the growing Latino birth rate and says he told former Republican House Speaker Newt Gingrich, "If you attack us, we will remember that, and you will never, ever have a Republican president in the future." Still, Latinos are still developing the cohesion that other groups have already created.

The documentary is produced by Phillip Rodriguez, a senior fellow at the Institute of Justice and Journalism at the USC Annenberg School for Communication. Its appearance on PBS follows agitation by Latinos for more inclusion in the network’s documentary programming.

Big Audience Expected for Obama-McCain Rematch

The Democratic presidential running mates Barack Obama and Joe Biden are doing a better job in the debates than their opponents, according to the latest Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll, Susan Davis reported Monday for the Wall Street Journal.

"By a 21 point margin, 50%-29%, voters said the Democrats had the debate edge over rival Republican running mates John McCain and Sarah Palin, while 10% of respondents said the two tickets were equally as good and 4% said neither was good.

"McCain and Obama will face off for the second of three debates Tuesday evening at Belmont University in Nashville, Tenn. This forum will be a town hall style format, where questions will come from the audience as well as viewers on-line. The debate doesn’t have a specific topic, and Tom Brokaw of NBC will moderate it.

"The two candidates will likely get a better viewing audience than the first debate – held on a Friday night — which was the least watched debate in modern history."

Meanwhile, Gwen Ifill‘s performance as moderator of Thursday’s vice presidential debate remained a topic of discussion.

"Ifill generally received positive, but notably mixed reviews from her television news colleagues on the questions she asked during Thursday’s Vice Presidential Debate, according to data gathered exclusively for TVSpy.com, using the iboqx¬†interactive ballot box," the TV tipsheet Shop Talk reported.

  • "68% of Ifill’s colleagues say Ifill’s book on African American politicians is a conflict of interest. 32% say the book is not a conflict of interest. Iboqx visitors were shown a video of Ifill describing the book in her own words.
  • "Ifill received an average score of 73 on the 30 substantive questions she asked during the debate, compared to a score of 83 given to PBS colleague Jim Lehrer for the questions he asked in the Presidential Debate the week before.
  • ¬†"In general, the shorter Ifill’s questions, the higher they were scored. Ifill’s 10-word question on gay marriage received the highest score. Ifill’s 87-word question on class warfare and her 63-word question on bailout received the lowest scores."

["Approximately 100 different TVSpy viewers interacted with the iboqx and
¬†questions presented," ShopTalk’s Thomas Petner told Journal-isms on Tuesday.]

CBS anchor Bob Schieffer, who is to moderate the final debate on Oct. 15, told the National Journal he thought Ifill received "a little bit of a bad rap" by critics who said her book-in-progress about black politics disqualified her as a moderator.

"I mean — and all I know about this is what I’ve literally read in the papers, but it’s my understanding this book is still in manuscript," he told Tammy Haddad. "It hasn’t even been set in type yet. She’s about in the middle of it and as it was explained to me, this is not a book about Barack Obama; it’s a book about black politicians and the gains they have made in recent years. So I thought that was a little bit of an unfair charge against her," Schieffer said.

Henderson Named Free Press Editorial Page Editor

Stephen HendersonStephen Henderson, deputy editorial editor at the Detroit Free Press, will become its editorial and opinion editor in January, the newspaper announced.

Henderson, 37, will oversee the editorial pages and lead the commentary and blogs on www.freep.com

He replaces Ron Dzwonkowski, 56, who after 10 years as
editorial page editor will become associate editor.

The announcement was one of several made last month in anticipation of the Nov. 9 departure of Executive Editor
Caesar Andrews, who holds the No. 2 newsroom job.

A Detroit native, Henderson worked with the Free Press in the mid-1990s, held editing posts with the Baltimore Sun and the Chicago Tribune, and in 2003, became the first mainstream newspaper reporter of color to regularly cover the U.S. Supreme Court. He did so for the old Knight Ridder newspapers, and then for the McClatchy Washington bureau. Henderson returned to the Free Press in 2007, and writes a weekly column.

Karen Lincoln Michel Promoted to AME in Green Bay

Karen Lincoln MichelKaren Lincoln Michel, president of Unity: Journalists of Color, has been named assistant managing editor of the Green Bay (Wis.) Press-Gazette, the paper reported on Thursday.

Michel has served as chief of the Press-Gazette’s Madison bureau since June 2005.

"In my travels as UNITY president, I’ve heard a lot of pessimism about the future of newspapers. But I think in these critical times, there is opportunity for growth in a new direction," she said in the story.

Michel, 49,¬†worked as a reporter for the La Crosse (Wis.)¬†Tribune and the Dallas Morning News. She also wrote columns on Native American issues for the New York Times Syndicate’s New America News Service. Michel, a member of the Ho-Chunk Nation, was part owner from 1987 to 2005 of News From Indian Country, published in Northern Wisconsin on the Lac Courte Oreilles Indian Reservation, the story said.

Debate Continues Over Coverage of Wall Street

Media second-guessing over¬†coverage of¬†Wall Street prior to last month’s financial meltdown continues.

"As news organizations chase exclusives about the Wall Street meltdown, they also are grappling with a troubling question: Why didn’t they see this coming?" Howard Kurtz wrote¬†on Monday in the Washington Post.

"After being burned by years of cheerleading before the dot-com collapse, the media warned repeatedly that the surge in housing prices might turn out to be a bubble. But the emphasis was generally on the potential toll on homeowners, not the banks that would be left holding bagfuls of bad loans. As in the savings-and-loan scandal of the late 1980s, the press was a day late and several dollars short."

In the Raleigh (N.C.) News & Observer on Sunday, public editor Ted Vaden said, "Here’s what I think readers are looking for: a) The latest news, as fast as you can provide it. b) Understanding of the causes and impact of the financial turmoil. c) What does it mean to me — my savings, investments, job, retirement?

"I think The N&O has done a good job with the hard news coverage but, as the comments indicate, can do better helping people understand and cope."

Short Takes

  • Helena Moreno left WDSU-TV to run for office.Indicted Rep. William Jefferson, D-La., led the Democratic Party primary’s seven-candidate field with 25.3 percent of the votes on Saturday, followed by former WDSU-TV news anchor and political newcomer Helena Moreno, who earned 19.9 percent of the vote in the contest for the congressional seat, Frank Donze and Michelle Krupa reported¬†Sunday in the New Orleans Times-Picayune. "The two will square off in a Nov. 4 party runoff that will appear on the same ballot as the highly anticipated presidential race. . . . Moreno, who is Hispanic, was the only non-African-American on the ballot."
  • "Haiti’s best known press freedom activist, Guyler Delva, sent out a frantic call for help yesterday morning. At least 70 journalists and media workers in the northern city of Gona?Øves are living in dire circumstances, Delva said in his e-mail. They need food, clothes, and shelter, as well as equipment, he specified. In short, ‘they have lost everything in the recent floods,’" Maria Salazar wrote¬†Thursday for the Committee to Protect Journalists.
  • "Black radio was once among the most influential engines of political and economic power for African Americans. Today it remains an important source of news and inspiration for black audiences. But thanks to new ratings technology being introduced this week, black-owned radio may be embarking on a fierce fight for its very survival," Kristal Brent Zook wrote¬†Monday on theRoot.com.¬† Groups protesting the new ratings mechanism¬†include the NAACP, the National Association of Black-Owned Broadcasters, Inner City Broadcasting, the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council, Spanish Broadcasting System and Univision Communications Inc.
  • "Ian Cameron has been named executive producer of ‘This Week With George Stephanopoulos,’ based in Washington," John Eggerton reported¬†for Broadcasting & Cable. "Cameron is married¬†to Obama adviser Susan Rice, which was pointed out by blog fishbowlDC. ‘We hire people based on their individual merits,’ said ABC spokesman Jeffrey Schneider. ‘In this case based on his 23 years in journalism and seven years as a senior producer on ‘World News.’ Not based on who their spouse happens to be.’"
  • "The death last year of Boubacar Bah, a Guinean tailor held in a New Jersey jail for overstaying his visa, showed immigration detention to be one of the most secretive corners of American life. But now Mr. Bah’s story is being retold in an unusually public way: in an online video game," Nina Bernstein reported¬†Saturday in the New York Times. "The video game (which can be found at http//homelandgitmo.com/) casts the player as a reporter seeking clues in the death of Mr. Bah, 52, who suffered a skull fracture and brain hemorrhages in the Elizabeth Detention Center in New Jersey."
  • "An Oct. 2 story in The Kansas City Star drew praise from some readers, but others found its tone problematic," reader advocate Derek Donovan wrote¬†Sunday¬†under the headline, "Does coverage of criminals glorify them?" "The debate centered on reporter Christine Vendel‘s coverage of the short life and funeral of Vincent Williams, who was killed by a clerk at a convenience store during an attempted armed robbery. Alvin Brooks, a community leader who spoke at the funeral, "spoke out against a society he says is making it increasingly difficult for African-American boys to grow into men," Vendel wrote.
  • In Fresno, Calif., "KSEE (Channel 24) confirmed Friday that news anchor Rich Rodriguez is no longer employed at the station." Mike Osegueda reported¬†Friday for the Fresno Bee. "Rodriguez said he parted ways with the station because he refused to take a 35% pay cut."
  • The Sam Milai cartoons in the Ohio State exhibit were found by his granddaughter in a suitcase in her mother's attic. The exhibit ends Dec. 31.The cartoons of Sam Milai (1908-1970), an artist and cartoonist for the Pittsburgh Courier for 33 years, will run through Dec. 31 at Ohio State University’s Cartoon Research Library," Editor & Publisher reported. "On Oct. 27, Milai’s work will be discussed at Ohio State by Assistant Professor of Women’s Studies and African-American and African Studies Dr. Rebecca Wanzo."
  • Herbert Lowe, the former president of the National Association of Black Journalists who left newspapers last year to work for the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, has edited a coffee-table-style book about the Caucus, "Continuing the Legacy: A Salute to the Congressional Black Caucus of the 110th Congress."
  • In Washington, panels of journalists that discuss politics at public forums are usually all-white. The Washington Post is flipping the script, however, fielding a panel of four at the Newseum at 7 p.m. on Oct. 13 in what could be a first. The panel discussing the current political campaign consists of the newspaper’s lead political reporter, Dan Balz, a white journalist, but three journalists of color: Marcia Davis, an assistant city editor; Kevin Merida, associate editor, and Jose Antonio Vargas, a Style section reporter. They will be introduced by Milton Coleman, deputy managing editor — and also a journalist of color.
  • "The Committee to Protect Journalists is alarmed by recent violence and intimidation against the Venezuelan media. Unfounded government accusations of media coup-plotting have compounded the problem, fostering a climate of fear among journalists in the weeks prior to the November 28 regional elections," the press-freedom group wrote¬† Monday to Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez.

Related posts

All-White Newsrooms Listed

richard

Black Reporters’ Network Presence Dismal

richard

John H. Johnson Dies at 87

richard

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.