Maynard Institute archives

N.Y. Times’ Cautious Step on “Illegal” Called “Cowardice”

NAHJ Scores Newspaper After Protesters Present Petitions

Fox News a Haven for Talk About Muslim Threats

Fired, Then Hired, Clemente Becomes Instant Celebrity

Politico Piece on N.Y. Times Draws Sexism Charges

Unity Urges Appointment of Pro-Diversity FCC Chair

Gracie Lawson-Borders Named Dean at Howard U.

Howard Chua-Eoan, News Director at Time, Retiring

Short Takes

Activists picket the New York Times building on Tuesday (Credit: Drop the I-Word

NAHJ Scores Newspaper After Protesters Present Petitions

After activists picketed the New York Times building Tuesday and delivered petitions with more than 70,000 signatures urging the newspaper to drop the term “illegal immigrant,” the Times announced a change in policy. But the National Association of Hispanic Journalists called the change “unacceptable” and cowardly.

Unity: Journalists for Diversity, which includes NAHJ, followed NAHJ on Thursday.

The immigration debate and the accompanying debate over terminology are likely to remain in the headlines. Reform bills are before Congress, and two brothers who immigrated from Chechnya are suspected of carrying out last week’s Boston marathon bombing.

On Tuesday, The New York Times updated its policies on how it uses the phrase ‘illegal immigrant’ in its coverage,” Christine Haughney reported for the New York Times. “The newspaper did not go as far as The Associated Press, and it will continue to allow the phrase to be used for ‘someone who enters, lives in or works in the United States without proper legal authorization.’ But it encourages reporters and editors to ‘consider alternatives when appropriate to explain the specific circumstances of the person in question, or to focus on actions.’ ” 

Haughney had noted, “This month, The Associated Press announced it would eliminate the use of ‘illegal immigrant’ entirely. The news agency wrote, ‘Except in direct quotes essential to the story, use “illegal” only to refer to an action, not a person: illegal immigration, but not illegal immigrant.’ “

While the AP style guidelines are widely followed, some news organizations have their own. Among the broadcast media, for instance, ABC News has used the terms “undocumented worker” and “undocumented immigrant,” network spokesman Jeffrey W. Schneider told Journal-isms.

Haughney continued, “Philip B. Corbett, the associate managing editor for standards, who oversees The Times’s style manual, made the announcement on Tuesday shortly after a group staged a protest in front of The New York Times headquarters and delivered more than 70,000 signatures to Jill Abramson, the executive editor of The Times, asking her to end the use of the phrase.

“Mr. Corbett said in a statement that editors had spent months deliberating the updated style change. He said he shared these changes ‘with key reporters and editors over the last couple of weeks.’ He said he recognized how sensitive this issue is for readers. . . . “

NAHJ said in its statement, “The National Association of Hispanic Journalists (NAHJ) is disappointed by the NY Times’ carelessness and cowardice on the dehumanizing term ‘illegal immigrant.’ The Times shift in policy is unacceptable in accurately and sensibly describing a group of hard working people. The Times attempt to have it both ways by ‘allowing the phrase to be used’ and only ‘encouraging reporters to consider alternatives’ is unacceptable. Instead of taking an opportunity to show it understands how destructive the term is to Latinos; the publication only demonstrated how disconnected it is to this group.”

The protesters included immigration activist Fernando Luis MirandaChavez, eldest son of the late farmworkers’ rights leader Cesar Chavez; Jose Antonio Vargas, the former journalist who publicly disclosed his unauthorized status in 2011; and members of the groups MoveOn.org and Presente.org. The Applied Research Center’s “Drop the I-Word” campaign also participated.

In a separate development, Luis Miranda, who just stepped down as director of Hispanic media for the Obama administration and is credited with improving access to the White House for Latino media, disclosed Tuesday that he was once an unauthorized immigrant.

When I was a kid, I dreamed of becoming a fighter pilot. One of my best friends with the same goal joined the Civil Air Patrol and encouraged me to join, too. I jumped at the chance. But then it happened. I needed a Social Security number and didn’t have one. I began to understand what it meant to be undocumented,” Miranda wrote in an op-ed piece in USA Today.

A 1986 law “allowed immigrants like myself a path to citizenship,” Miranda wrote. [Updated April 25.]

On CNN’s “Anderson Cooper 360°” on Tuesday, Cooper discussed the resilience of Boston residents with the Rev. Liz Walker of Roxbury Presbyterian Church. Walker ended her anchor role at Boston’s WBZ in 2005 after 25 years. (Video)

Fox News a Haven for Talk About Muslim Threats

In the days following the Boston Marathon bombings, Fox News has become a haven for talk about the extreme threats posed to the United States by Muslims,Jack Murchinson wrote Wednesday for the Huffington Post. “Day after day, the network’s hosts and pundits have warned about an Islamic menace which is poised to take down the country.

“At the most extreme has been ‘Fox News liberal’ Bob Beckel, whose call on ‘The Five’ to bar or severely restrict Muslim students from coming into America seemed to startle even Dana Perino, George Bush‘s former spokeswoman. Beckel stuck by his comments on Tuesday, saying that some of the 75,000 Muslim students in American schools are likely to harbor terrorist ambitions.

” ‘It’s a risky situation,’ he said. . . . “

Fired North Dakota anchor A.J. Clemente landed a job on "Live With Kelly and Mic

Fired, Then Hired, Clemente Becomes Instant Celebrity

He was hired. And then he was fired. And now he’s been hired — for a night — as a celebrity correspondent,Ann Oldenburg reported Wednesday for USA Today.

A.J. Clemente, the North Dakota anchor who shot to fame for dropping an f-bomb on the air on his first day on the job only to be immediately fired, stopped by Live With Kelly and Michael today.

“And the two co-hosts offered him a job.

” ‘A.J., you know, I’ve got to tell you, that this clip of you has captivated all of us,’ Kelly Ripa told him. ‘It’s taken us on a wild ride. What exactly was going on in your head when that happened? Were you aware that you were on the air?’

“Replied Clemente, ‘I had no clue.’ And there was a bleep, even though he didn’t curse. The show’s control room bleeped him to be funny. . . .”

Politico Piece on N.Y. Times Draws Sexism Charges

Has Jill Abramson, executive editor of The New York Times, ‘lost the newsroom’?Tom McGeveran asked Wednesday for Capital New York.

A story posted last night by Politico’s Dylan Byers characterizes Abramson as a woman on the verge of a newsroom breakdown. The culprit is her personality, but also, to be fair, the way that personality has manifested itself in a few decisions, none of which were particularly key decisions.

“Today, the story has readers charging sexist bias, thin sourcing, and a certain naivete about how the great big newsrooms work. I don’t think any of these is really applicable to Byers’ reporting, but this article does speak volumes about all three issues. . . .”

The Byers article opens with an anecdote about Managing Editor Dean Baquet, the highest ranking black journalist at the newspaper, who was said to have competed with Abramson for the top job after Bill Keller stepped down in 2011.

Unity Urges Appointment of Pro-Diversity FCC Chair

Unity: Journalists for Diversity urged President Obama Wednesday “to consider the diversity of America’s news coverage and news companies as you evaluate candidates to chair the Federal Communications Commission.”

Unity also joined “Fifty organizations, most representing minority constituencies, [who] have asked the White House to nominate two new FCC commissioners, including a replacement chairman — who will make minority and female participation in media a priority,John Eggerton reported for Broadcasting & Cable.

Unity did not urge Obama to appoint a woman of color to the chairmanship, as the National Association of Black Owned Broadcasters did this month, but the letter from President Tom Arviso Jr. said, “The next chairman or chairwoman of the FCC will shape the future of news for diverse communities in America”  and named “the principles we believe should serve as core values for any future appointment.”

Mignon Clyburn

The Unity coalition asserted its opposition to additional consolidation of the nation’s media; urged the FCC “to conduct research on tracking the number of minority, women and LGBT owned broadcast stations”; said that “diversity should be measured and factored into approval or rejection of all licensing and re-licensing applications” and that “universal access to the Internet is a basic right.”

Eggerton reported, “The White House is said by various sources to be vetting the current nominee for chairman — former cable and telecom association exec Tom Wheeler is said to be the leading candidate — and could announce a nominee, as well as a Republican to be paired with him or her, within the next couple of weeks.

“If commissioner Mignon Clyburn is named interim chair” — she is the senior Democrat after outgoing chair Julius Genachowski — “she could be in that post for several months and have an opportunity to put her imprint on the issue as the first African-American woman chair. . . . “

Unity includes the National Association of Hispanic Journalists, the Asian American Journalists Association, the Native American Journalists Association and the National Lesbian & Gay Journalists Association.

Gracie Lawson-Borders Named Dean at Howard U.

Gracie Lawson-BordersGracie Lawson-Borders, associate dean at the University of Wyoming College of Arts and Sciences and professor in communication and journalism there, has been named dean of the Howard University School of Communications, Howard announced on Tuesday.

Lawson-Borders is a former journalist who worked as a reporter and editor at the Akron Beacon Journal in Ohio, the Oakland Press in Michigan and the Chicago Tribune, the university said.

She succeeds Jannette Dates, who had been dean or acting dean for 17½ years and associate dean for five, and Interim Dean Dr. Chuka Onwumechili, who served in the post for the last year.

Lawson-Borders is also a former director of the African American & Diaspora Studies program at Wyoming and is working on her second book, about digital business models and strategies for media organizations, the university said.

In September, the university Board of Trustees approved two new undergraduate programs and a new doctoral program in the School of Communications as a part of the university’s “academic renewal” efforts.

The new undergraduate programs are strategic, legal and management communications, and media, journalism and film. The doctoral program is in communication, culture and media studies.

The School of Communications has 1,050 students.

Short Takes

Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor

Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.

Related posts

Morning-After Debate

richard

NABJ Asks Editor & Publisher to Discuss All-White Cover Story

richard

Michael Days Moving to Philly Inquirer as ME

richard

Leave a Comment