Tsarnaevs Are White, but Look More Like the “Other”
Up to 5 Senior Blacks Leaving USA Today, Gannett
T.J. Holmes Says He’s Officially a Free Agent
Could Fact-Checkers Have Saved Howard Kurtz?
Media Were Silent on Gay Player Who Came Out in ’70s
Denver Post Joins Papers Dropping “Illegal Immigrant”
G.M. of Morgan State Radio Heading to Orlando Station
Four in 5 Americans Oppose Changing “Redskins” Name
U.S. to Train Central American Journalists in Security
Tsarnaevs Are White, but Look More Like the “Other”
“This is how brofiling actually works in real life,” Hari Stephen Kumar wrote Thursday for his “brofiling” blog. “The Week Magazine ran with this image as their cover sketch.
“Just so it is said, clearly and unambiguously: the Tsarnaev brothers are white guys. They are white. The FBI’s own wanted poster for Dzhokhar Tsarnaev lists his race as ‘white’, but you would never know it from the cover image on The Week.
“Hold up the cover to someone else, and ask them how many white people they can see on the cover. Chances are they will identify Gabby Giffords on the top left and the image of the Boston policemen (all white men) on the top right, but how about those two guys in the center? Nope, not a chance that anyone would say these caricatures look white.
“Why? Because in addition to being white they are also ‘Muslim’, which is the current dehumanizing ‘Other’ label that whiteness has constructed as a sanctioned target for violence in US popular culture.
“This is how white privilege works in media representations and everyday life: when the criminal suspects are demonstrably white men, seize upon any aspect of difference and magnify it such that they become Othered, non-white, and menacing. If it is too hard to do so, simply dismiss them as aberrations and isolated cases of insanity. This is also how white culture, specifically the process of whiteness in conjunction with white privilege, portrays several non-white identities, including those that are now considered white but at one time were decidedly not so. . . .”
The Week magazine did not respond to a request for comment.
The episode is reminiscent of Time magazine’s darkening of O.J. Simpson’s face during his 1994 murder trial to make him appear more menacing.
The well-respected weekly calls itself “A comprehensive, balanced distillation of national and international news, opinions and ideas.” Its subscriber base is just a fraction of Time’s 3.2 million: It had a total paid and verified circulation of 561,459 for the six months ending Dec. 21, according to the Alliance for Audited Media.
Up to 5 Senior Blacks Leaving USA Today, Gannett
As many as five senior black journalists at USA Today and Gannett News Service are taking a buyout, depleting the top ranks of journalists of color at “the nation’s newspaper.”
Four of the five confirmed their departure: Geri Coleman Tucker, deputy managing editor; Robert Robinson, deputy managing editor/copy editors; Gary Rawlins, global editions editor; and reporter Larry Bivins of Gannett News Service.
“Early retirements were offered to USA TODAY employees who were at least 55 years old and had 15 years of service. They were offered two weeks pay for each year of service — with a cap of one year of pay,” USA Today spokeswoman Heidi Zimmerman told Journal-isms by email Friday. She would not disclose the number taking the buyout.
“Yes, it’s true,” Bivins messaged Journal-isms. “After 36 years in the business, starting at The Cleveland Call & Post, a black weekly, I’m hanging it up. At least for a while. The timing is good for me . . . I’ll be 64 in November, giving me just two more years before full Social Security eligibility. I’ll get a paycheck for almost a year. I’m not quite sure what I want to do. I imagine I’ll be open to freelance possibilities. But for a couple of months, at least, I plan on doing nothing but playing tennis every day. And clear my head!
“May 15 would have been my 20th anniversary with Gannett, all in Washington. I started in 1993 as an urban affairs/race relations reporter for The Detroit News, then moved over to Gannett News Service in 1998. I was a regional reporter, spent time as a regional editor, then went back to reporting when the bureau downsized in 2009 — I had just returned to work after a six-week disability for a hip replacement. . . .”
Tucker said she was “embarking on a great faith journey.” She said she had spent 23 years at USA Today, “30 at Gannett all total because i was also a regional managing editor at Gannett News Service.” Tucker has been deputy managing editor/Money at USA Today and managing editor/Midwest for Gannett News Service from 1986 to 1993.
She added, “I’m looking for exciting, new opportunities.”
Rawlins, who has been with USA Today for 28 years, said he hopes to teach at a university in the area.
Robinson, deputy managing editor/Sports before a reorganization, messaged, “After 39 years at Gannett, the last 30½ with USA TODAY, I decided to take the early retirement package. I have had 39 wonderful years in the business, including being a founding member of the USA TODAY staff, and felt the timing was right to take a step back. . . . As for what’s next, I have no immediate plans other than to take a month or so to just enjoy the family, visit my aging mother in Florida and then look for my next employment opportunity — or whatever God has in store for me.” [Updated May 5]
T.J. Holmes Says He’s Officially a Free Agent
Black Entertainment Television finally acknowledged Thursday that it will not bring back T.J. Holmes’ “Don’t Sleep!” late night news/talk show, eight months after its initial launch. Holmes told Journal-isms on Friday, “I’m a completely free agent.”
Holmes left his job as a CNN weekend anchor in December 2011 for BET, which developed a half-hour late-night show for him that targeted African American viewers but was intended to have more in common with Jon Stewart than with traditional journalism.
“But the show, which aired Monday through Thursday, failed to draw a significant audience,” R. Thomas Umstead wrote Thursday for Multichannel News. “After generating a series-high 1 million viewers for its Oct. 9 episode, the series averaged less than 400,000 viewers before being revamped into a weekly, one-hour format on Nov. 14. The last new episode of the series aired Dec. 19.”
However, BET refused to say it was canceling the show, even as it turned its attention toward the reality show “The Real Husbands of Hollywood.“
Holmes told Journal-isms by telephone, “I will never, ever regret thinking that my heart was in the right place,” a young black man taking his skills “to do something that was not being done for our community,” that is, providing a daily news show geared toward African Americans. “You learn from the mistakes, there are questions I should have asked, things that should have been cleared up,” but reaching the black community in that way was “an opportunity I would love to have” again, Holmes said.
Umstead wrote, “In a statement, BET said Don’t Sleep ‘delivered smart social commentary on significant issues important to African Americans with the nation’s most prominent thought leaders. BET remains committed to being a resource for our audience on issues that directly affect the African American community.’ “
Could Fact-Checkers Have Saved Howard Kurtz?
The saga of media writer Howard Kurtz, who “parted ways” with Newsweek and the Daily Beast after an embarrassing error this week, was part of the buzz Thursday night at the American Magazine Awards in New York. Jim Nelson, editor-in-chief of GQ, accepted one of the honors.
“Howard Kurtz, who wrongly accused NBA player Jason Collins of not mentioning his earlier engagement to a woman when he came out this week, could have been saved from his mistake by magazine factcheckers, GQ Editor-in-Chief suggested when his magazine won in the reporting category,” Nat Ives reported for AdAge.
For the most part, reconstructions of Kurtz’s fall have not addressed the role of the website in failing to catch his errors.
Dylan Byers and Katie Glueck wrote Thursday night for Politico, “At the height of his influence, Howard Kurtz was widely regarded as the most influential media reporter and critic in the country. But in recent years, erroneous reporting and careless errors reduced him to fodder for the media reporters and critics who followed in his footsteps.
“No single event has dealt such a crushing blow to Kurtz’s reputation as Thursday’s decision to ‘part ways’ — after a serious mistake in a story about gay basketball player Jason Collins — with The Daily Beast, where he has served as columnist and Washington bureau chief since leaving a long, illustrious career with The Washington Post in 2010. . . .”
They added, “sources at the Daily Beast and CNN, who spoke to POLITICO on the condition of anonymity, said there were several reasons for the breakup: For one thing, Kurtz had a string of high-profile mistakes on his record and that had become a source of embarrassment for The Daily Beast. For another, he commanded a hefty paycheck, despite turning out fewer scoops than in the past. . . .”
“But perhaps the main factor that led Kurtz out the door, several sources said, was the same quality that had fueled his rise in the first place decades ago: a hyperactive work ethic that ended up dividing his attentions and ultimately proved unsustainable. . . .”
Andrew Kirk, a spokesman for the Daily Beast, did not respond to a question about whether Kurtz’s work went through copy editors. The fateful entry about Collins was described as a “blog post,” which at many publications means it is posted without editing.
Meanwhile, CNN has decided not to remove Kurtz as host of his Sunday morning media show. “There has been no status change with Howard Kurtz, he remains the host of ‘Reliable Sources‘. He will address this issue on the program this weekend,” a CNN spokeswoman told inquiring journalists.
Daily Beast Editor-in-Chief Tina Brown tweeted Thursday that Kurtz and the Daily Beast had “parted company … we wish him well.”
“A statement from Brown highlighted moves the website is taking to bolster its coverage of Washington, including with new columnists such as Jon Favreau, Joshua [DuBois] and Stuart Stevens,” Ryan Nakashima reported for the Associated Press.
DuBois, an African American, left his position as faith adviser for President Obama in February.
- Michael Calderone, Huffington Post: Howard Kurtz Had Larger Daily Download Role Than Other Advisory Board Members
- Matt K. Lewis, the Week: Let’s all stop taking swings at Howard Kurtz
Media Were Silent on Gay Player Who Came Out in ’70s
“A few months back, the Baltimore Ravens’ Brendon Ayanbadejo, an outspoken advocate for LGBT rights, told USA Today that he thought the first player in the three major sports to out himself would be a baseball player: ‘The religious roots are a lot deeper in basketball and football. With that being said, I think baseball players are more open-minded,’ ” Allen Barra reported Friday for the Atlantic.
“What Ayanbadejo didn’t know was that one baseball player already had. This week’s coming out by NBA player Jason Collins is momentous, but the Jackie Robinson of gay rights was Glenn Burke, who played for the Los Angeles Dodgers and Oakland A’s from 1976 to 1979. He tried to change sports culture three decades ago — but back then, unlike now, sports culture wasn’t ready for a change.
“Burke made no secret of his sexual orientation to the Dodgers front office, his teammates, or friends in either league. He also talked freely with sportswriters, though all of them ended up shaking their heads and telling him they couldn’t write that in their papers. Burke was so open about his sexuality that the Dodgers tried to talk him into participating in a sham marriage. (He wrote in his autobiography that the team offered him $75,000 to go along with the ruse.) He refused. In a bit of irony that would seem farcical if it wasn’t so tragic, one of the Dodgers who tried to talk Burke into getting ‘married,’ was his manager, Tommy Lasorda, whose son Tom Jr. died from AIDS complications in 1991. To this day, Lasorda Sr. refuses to acknowledge his son’s homosexuality.
“Burke, who also died of AIDS-related causes in 1995, came out to the world outside baseball in a 1982 article for Inside Sports and even followed it up shortly after with an appearance on The Today Show with Bryant Gumbel. But his story was greeted by the rest of the news media and the baseball establishment, including Burke’s former teammates and baseball commissioner Bowie Kuhn, with silence. Even his superb autobiography, Out at Home, which published the year he died, failed to stir open conversation about homosexuality in sports. Practically no one in the sports-writing community would acknowledge that Burke was gay or report stories that followed up on his admission. . . .”
“Out: the Glenn Burke Story,” a documentary featuring Burke, debuted in November 2010 in a San Francisco theater, accompanied by a television broadcast the same night on Comcast SportsNet Bay Area.
- Perry Bacon Jr., the Grio: Silence of opponents illustrates growing acceptance of LGBT rights
- Leonardo Blair, Christian Post: ESPN’s Chris Broussard: ‘Though I’m Getting a Lot of Hate, God Is Being Glorified’
- Donna Brazile, CNN: But can the dude play?
- Mary C. Curtis, Washington Post: Is Jason Collins the Jackie Robinson of 2013?
- Mike Fleming Jr., Deadline Hollywood: Will Gay Hoopster Revelation Drive Home Jamie Lee Curtis-Produced Pic About First Openly Gay Baseball Player?
- Justice B. Hill, BET: Why We Should Respect Chris Broussard’s Opinion
- Reginald Johnson, Metuchen Edison Area Branch NAACP, letter, MyCentralJersey.com | Courier News | Home News Tribune: Tough being gay in sports? Ask Glenn Burke
- Saeed Jones, BuzzFeed: Yes, It Matters That Jason Collins Is Black And Gay
- John Koblin, Deadspin: Why ESPN’s Chris Broussard Came Out As A Bigot
- Ron Kroichick, San Francisco Chronicle: Film examines struggle of gay athlete Glenn Burke (2010)
- Chris Murray blog: It’s Time to End Homophobia and Anti-Gay Bigotry in the African-American Community
- Jeff Poor, Daily Caller: MoveOn petition urges ESPN to suspend Chris Broussard
- Armstrong Williams, the Shadow League: Jason Collins And The Plague Of Identity Politics
- Phillip B. Wilson, Indianapolis Star: Colts notes: Players would accept a gay teammate
Denver Post Joins Papers Dropping “Illegal Immigrant”
“During the past decade I have had several conversations with groups and individuals that eventually landed on use of the term illegal immigrant to describe those who have unlawfully come to the United States,” Greg Moore, editor of the Denver Post, told readers Thursday.
“I have heard all kinds of arguments. I always tensed up when someone argued illegal immigrant was the same as racial epithets used to describe blacks and Jews. I still believe those comparisons are wrongheaded. But other examples stayed with me. I remember once being told that a young girl cried upon seeing a relative described as an illegal immigrant.
“Yesterday, I decided The Denver Post will no longer use the term ‘illegal immigrant’ when describing a person in the country unlawfully. If we know the actual circumstances we will describe them. The word ‘illegal’ will not be applied to a person, only an action. . . .”
The Denver Post entry on “illegal immigration” now reads:
“Entering or residing in a country in violation of civil or criminal law. Except in direct quotes essential to the story, use illegal only to refer to an action, not a person: illegal immigration, but not illegal immigrant. Acceptable variations include living in or entering a country illegally or without legal permission.
“Except in direct quotations, do not use the terms illegal alien, an illegal, illegals, undocumented aliens or undocumented workers. Use the unmodified word immigrant only for people who have entered the U.S. lawfully.
“Do not describe people as violating immigration laws without attribution.
“If possible, specify how someone entered the country illegally and from where. Crossed the border? Overstayed a visa? What nationality?
“People who were brought into the country as children should not be described as having immigrated illegally. For people granted a temporary right to remain in the U.S. under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, use temporary resident status, with details on the program lower in the story.”
- Hugo Balta, National Association of Hispanic Journalists: NAHJ Applauds the Denver Post for Its Decision to Drop the I Word
- Kevin Bogardus and Russell Berman, African Globe: Caribbean and African Immigrants Getting Blocked in New Immigration Bill
- Joel Campbell, Columbia Journalism Review: Four Corners coverage: immigration reform (April 29)
- Charles D. Ellison, Uptown: How Black Folks Are Shut Out of the Immigration Debate (April 29)
- María Hinojosa with former Mexican Ambassador Arturo Sarukhan, “Latino USA,” NPR: Where Is Mexico on U.S. Immigration Reform? (podcast)
- Maria Hinojosa, “Latino USA,” NPR: Lost Women (podcast)
Short Takes
- The Atlantic won a National Magazine Award in New York Thursday for its website as well as for “Fear of a Black President,” a September article by senior editor Ta-Nehisi Coates. Coates won in the essays and criticism category. James Bennet, editor-in-chief, accepted on Coates’ behalf. Coates blogged about the honor the next day. List of winners.
- George E. Curry, editor-in-chief of the National Newspaper Publishers Association News Service, traveled to southern Africa with Jesse Jackson Sr. on a nine-day trip that ended Friday. In Pretoria, South Afria, Jackson was presented the Order of the Companions of O.R. Tambo, the highest award a non-South African can receive, for his efforts to held end apartheid in the country. Jackson condemned sanctions on Zimbabwe.
- “Al Jazeera executives have been touring the country and rolling out announcements of new bureaus ahead of Al Jazeera America’s launch later this year,” Dylan Byers reported Thursday for Politico. Al Jazeera plans 12 bureaus, in New York; Washington; Miami; Nashville, Tenn.; Chicago; New Orleans; Detroit; Dallas; Denver; Los Angeles; San Francisco and Seattle. Ehab Al Shihabi, executive director for international operations for Al Jazeera Media Network, told Journal-isms the network had 22,000 job applications for 800 positions.
- “Mountain Dew’s problems with cultural sensitivity this week culminated with the pulling of its ‘Felicia the Goat’ spot today, after suffering similar marketing damage when the family of Emmett Till during the last several days denounced the brand’s sponsorship of rap artist Lil’ Wayne,” Christopher Heine wrote Wednesday for Adweek. He added, “It appears obvious that some brands desperately want to tap young urbanites while signing up their edgiest musical heroes, such as Lil’ Wayne, Ross and Tyler, The Creator — who produced Mountain Dew’s spot. But do six-figure-salaried marketers actually know what they are doing while attempting to reach the street? And are these examples once again showing the advertising world’s lack of diversity? . . .”
- “FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai has turned into a hero for AM Broadcasters,” RadioInk reported April 25. “His desire to save the AM band, stemming from his love for AM radio stations, is exactly what AM broadcasters need at such a crucial time. With interference at an all-time high and so many other ways to consume much clearer content, AM radio might simply die without such an important advocate in such an important position. . . .”
- In a profile Thursday of Geneva Overholser, leaving in June after five years as director of the journalism school at the Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, Rachel Bracker of the student Daily Trojan quoted Overholser, “I’m really proud of how diverse our faculty is and how diverse our student body is. We know that the future of journalism is not all white and it’s not all men.” Last year, Annenberg was awarded the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication’s Equity & Diversity Award.
- “Does everything on your airwaves and website get a second set of eyes? Are those eyes trained to find more than grammatical errors?” Amy Tardif asks for the Radio Television Digital News Association. “Apparently not every newsroom is doing enough. But now there’s a guide book that will help.” RTDNA has produced a book on plagiarism. “The book defines the problem, tells how to build barriers to plagiarism including who does it and why as well as policies that can help. The writers agree the solution is attribution,” Tardif wrote.
- “Eight days after getting a press pass from San Diego police, freelance videographer J.C. Playford saw his media credential confiscated and revoked Tuesday after a standoff at the San Ysidro border crossing,” Ken Stone wrote Wednesday for Patch in Ramona, Calif. He added, “Playford posted three YouTube videos Wednesday depicting his exchanges with authorities on and near the bridge, where he says he had stopped to film a K-9 drug search of a car passing into the United States. ‘This is what a dictatorship looks like,’ Playford says in one video during his time talking to police. . . .”
- It’s not exactly the same as chronicling what happens to the only person of color in a newsroom, but some situations might seem familiar. Heben Nigatu of BuzzFeed posted “27 Things You Had To Deal With As The Only Black Kid In Your Class” on Thursday.
- Asked why the media don’t draw more attention to the racial dynamics surrounding the nation’s first African American president, poet and essayist Ishmael Reed replied in an interview with PolicyMic, “The media knows there are racial angles, but they don’t want to alienate their white subscribers. They view their audience as the so-called majority, and to bring up racism as a factor would be seen as a turn-off. They couldn’t sell their products. They coddle their white subscribers by ignoring white pathology and blaming all of the social ills on blacks in order to get ratings. . . .”
- On Saturday at 10 p.m. and Sunday at 1:30 a.m., C-SPAN is rebroadcasting a discussion of the coverage of the Trayvon Martin case led by New York Times op-ed columnist Charles M. Blow, who also talks about the differences between opinion journalism and straight news reporting. At 10:30 a.m. Sunday, the Tavis Smiley Forum discusses “Latino Nation” with Rep. Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., and GOP strategist Ana Navarro.
- The International Press Institute Friday “hailed the approval by the Cabinet of Trinidad and Tobago of a bill that would partially decriminalise defamation in the country,” Scott Griffen wrote for IPI. “The bill has now been sent to Parliament, for what is hoped to be swift passage. . . .”
- “The prize-winning investigations editor of Colombia’s top newsmagazine said Thursday that he believes a roadside attack on him by gunmen who put five bullets in his car was related to his work,” Libardo Cardona wrote Thursday for the Associated Press. “Ricardo Calderon, 42, was uninjured in Wednesday night’s shooting by at least two gunmen after he had stopped by the roadside to urinate in Girardot, a valley town southwest of Bogota. . . .”
Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor
Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.
