Articles Feature

Journalists in Minn. Beaten, Thrown to Ground

by richard026630

To Asian American: ‘Do You Speak English?’
Glover to Lead Newsroom at Minn. Public Radio
Reporter Quits Over Race Issues, ‘General Toxicity’
Jan. 6 Rioters Say They Were Acting as Journalists
Bleeding Shooting Victim Jumps into News Car
How Much Do Journalists Need Western Classics?
Robin Washington, ‘Jew of Color,’ Joins Forward

‘Is My Fellow Congressman Trying to Kill Me?’:
From a Member, What Disinformation Has Wrought

Support Journal-isms

Homepage cartoon by Steve Sack/Star Tribune

Rosemary Nevils, right, held sage as people took turns speaking to protesters. Nevils and others wore bathrobes in support of Samira Hassan, who was arrested in her bathrobe Wednesday outside her apartment, near the protesters. (Credit: Renee Jones Schneider/Star Tribune)

To Asian American: ‘Do You Speak English?’

“Joshua Rashaad McFadden, a freelance photographer working for the New York Times, said he was covering protests outside the police station” in Brooklyn Center, Minn., Tuesday night “when officers moved in to arrest protesters,” Ryan Faircloth reported Saturday for the Star Tribune in Minneapolis.

“McFadden (pictured, by Spectrum News), who is Black, said he and another journalist were in a vehicle about to leave the area when officers surrounded them and beat on the windows with wooden batons, yelling for them to get out.

“The officers pulled the other journalist, who was white, from the car and then beat McFadden with their sticks as they tried to get him out, he said.

” ‘They’re hitting me, they’re hitting my camera as if they’re trying to break my camera lens, over and over again, telling me to get out, but I clearly couldn’t get out because now they’re blocking the doors,’ said McFadden, who added that he told officers he was a journalist but that they did not believe him. When the other journalist said McFadden was press, the officers let them go.

” ‘I am assuming because I am a Black photographer that they would not believe me or look at my press credential until who I was with said, “Oh, he’s with the Times,” ‘ McFadden said. He said he was detained a second time while covering protests Friday, and once again, it took another photojournalist backing him up for officers to believe he was a journalist. . . .”

Josephine Harvey added Sunday for HuffPost, “Attorney Leita Walker wrote on behalf of nearly 30 journalism and news organizations to Gov. Tim Walz (D) detailing multiple such examples.

“In one case, CNN producer Carolyn Sung was grabbed by her backpack and thrown to the ground by state troopers while she was trying to comply with a dispersal order on Tuesday. She did not resist, showed her credentials and repeatedly identified herself as press, but was nonetheless arrested, the letter said.

“Despite hearing Sung, who is Asian American, identifying herself and saying that the zip ties on her wrists were too tight, one trooper yelled at her, ‘Do you speak English?’

“The male security agent hired by CNN to work with her was also briefly detained but was released when he showed his credentials. Sung was taken to Hennepin County Jail in a prisoner transport bus.

“ ‘She was patted down and searched by a female officer who put her hands down Sung’s pants and in her bra, fingerprinted, electronically body-scanned, and ordered to strip and put on an orange uniform before attorneys working on her behalf were able to locate her and secure her release, a process that took more than two hours,’ the letter said.

“The mistreatment of the press at the protests has been condemned online by numerous media organizations. CNN anchors Brian Stelter and Jake Tapper called out Sung’s incident in particular. . . .”

Faircloth’s story summarized Saturday, “Journalists covering protests in Brooklyn Center last week following the fatal police shooting of Daunte Wright say they have been assaulted, pepper-sprayed and detained by law enforcement officers despite showing their credentials and a Friday court order barring officers from arresting or using force against members of the media.

“In an interview Saturday, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz said these incidents are ‘unacceptable in every circumstance.’ He said law enforcement leaders will communicate to officers guarding the Brooklyn Center police headquarters that they must follow the court order and let journalists do their jobs.

” ‘Democracy cannot thrive without a free and fair and safe press,’ Walz said. ‘These individual incidents will be looked into. They just need to make sure they don’t happen in the first place.’

“On Friday, a federal judge issued a temporary restraining order barring officers from arresting or using force — such as less-lethal projectiles, pepper spray and batons — against journalists. . . .”

Glover to Lead Newsroom at Minn. Public Radio

Sarah Glover (pictured), who has had to reinvent herself more than once in the changing media business, has done so again. She left NBC, where she was manager of social media strategy for NBC Owned Television Stations, to become managing editor of MPR News at Minnesota Public Radio, MPR announced Monday.

“Glover brings 23 years of experience in local journalism, including more than a decade at the Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Daily News as a staff photographer,” MPR said in a news release. “While at the Daily News, she led the video team on the Pulitzer Prize-winning ‘Tainted Justice’ series.”

“Glover has served two terms as president of the National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ), which she led from 2015 to 2019. Hers was the first two-term presidency in NABJ’s history, and during her tenure, she created the NABJ Black Male Media Project, which examines the portrayal of Black men in the media. She also played a crucial role in the Associated Press Stylebook’s move to capitalize the ‘B’ in Black to describe people and communities.  

“ ‘I grew up in a household where public media was ever present and it influenced the person I am today,’ said Glover. ‘I’m fortunate that I can help shape the news products that will speak to the next generation of MPR listeners and digital audiences. I look forward to working with MPR’s talented journalists to build bridges and cover the state of Minnesota with authenticity and zeal.’

“As managing editor, Glover will lead a team of more than 40 reporters, photojournalists and editors and will be responsible for editorial decisions and planning across MPR News platforms. . . .”
​

‘Doing right isn’t always popular nor favorable,’ Porshia Riley said. (Credit: YouTube)

Reporter Quits Over Race Issues, ‘General Toxicity’

“Former KOCO reporter Porshia Riley posted a 17-minute video on YouTube explaining her recent resignation from the Oklahoma City ABC affiliate,” Kevin Eck reported Friday for TVSpy.

“She said she resigned after disagreeing with Hearst’s handling of an investigation into racism, racial bias, lack of equity and ‘overall general toxicity’ within KOCO.

“ ‘LIFE UPDATE: I decided to resign from KOCO this week,’ she posted on Twitter. ‘My decision comes after several mishandled race-related incidents that contradict what I stand for and are frankly gross and unacceptable. I know this is an unpopular thing to do and could cost me, but I know doing right isn’t always popular nor favorable.’ . . .”

Eck also wrote, “A KOCO spokesperson told TVSpy, ‘We have accepted Porsha’s resignation and wish her well. It is our policy not to comment on personnel matters, except to say that we wish her the best’.”

Jan. 6 Rioters Say They Were Acting as Journalists

“The Trump supporters who stormed the U.S. Capitol in January created a trove of self-incriminating evidence, thoroughly documenting their actions and words in videos and social media posts,” Michael Kunzelman and Jacques Billeaud reported Sunday for the Associated Press. “Now some of the camera-toting people in the crowd are claiming they were only there to record history as journalists, not to join a deadly insurrection.

“It’s unlikely that any of the self-proclaimed journalists can mount a viable defense on the First Amendment’s free speech grounds, experts say. They face long odds if video captured them acting more like rioters than impartial observers. But as the internet has broadened and blurred the definition of a journalist, some appear intent on trying. . . .”

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Ty Milburn (@tymilburn12)

Bleeding Shooting Victim Jumps into News Car

“Two people were shot blocks apart hours after a vigil for DMX in Mount Vernon Wednesday night – and one of the victims ran into the News 12 vehicle at the scene for safety,” the local news service in Westchester County, N.Y., reported Thursday.

“News 12’s Ty Milburn and his photographer Dan Foley were on scene at the Fourth Street Playground covering the candlelight vigil for DMX. They were still at the scene hours later when one of the incidents occurred.

“Milburn said he and Foley ran into the News 12 vehicle, and shortly after that, a bleeding victim got into the back of the car and asked to stay there for cover. . . .”

“This has been one of my craziest weeks of reporting.. EVER,” Milburn wrote on Instagram. “I dodged bullets and helped a shooting victim who jumped into our @news12 crew car and started to bleed out. Thanks to the extraordinary photojournalist @danfoley9 for holding me down. He was the calm in a stormy night!”

The Thinker in ‘The Gates of Hell’ at the Musée Rodin in Paris.

How Much Do Journalists Need Western Classics?

Today, “one of America’s greatest Black institutions, Howard University, is diminishing the light of wisdom and truth that inspired [Frederick] Douglass, [Martin Luther] King and countless other freedom fighters,” scholar Cornel West and Jeremy Tate, founder and chief executive officer of the Classic Learning Test, wrote Monday for The Washington Post.

“Amid a move for educational ‘prioritization,’ Howard University is dissolving its classics department. Tenured faculty will be dispersed to other departments, where their courses can still be taught. But the university has sent a disturbing message by abolishing the department.

“Academia’s continual campaign to disregard or neglect the classics is a sign of spiritual decay, moral decline and a deep intellectual narrowness running amok in American culture. Those who commit this terrible act treat Western civilization as either irrelevant and not worthy of prioritization or as harmful and worthy only of condemnation,” West and Tate (pictured) continued.

“Sadly, in our culture’s conception, the crimes of the West have become so central that it’s hard to keep track of the best of the West. We must be vigilant and draw the distinction between Western civilization and philosophy on the one hand, and Western crimes on the other. The crimes spring from certain philosophies and certain aspects of the civilization, not all of them. . . .”

The Society for Classical Studies noted Friday that Howard is the only historically black college or university with a classics department. “The Board of Directors of the Society for Classical Studies strongly supports all the faculty, including all non-tenure track faculty, and students in the Department of Classics. The SCS Classics Advisory Service will continue to make itself available to all at Howard in order to advise and support the department, its programs, students, and all faculty,” it declared.

Howard University spokespersons were not immediately available for comment.

Robin Washington, ‘Jew of Color,’ Joins Forward

“Robin Washington (pictured), an acclaimed veteran journalist and early organizer of Jews of color, is the Forward’s new Editor-at-Large, a flagship position aimed at elevating and expanding diverse voices,” the Forward announced on Tuesday.

“Washington, a longtime senior editor, columnist, radio host and TV/film documentarian across mainstream and ethnic media, was one of the founders of the Alliance of Black Jews back in 1995, and among the first to use the term ‘Jew of color,’ in [a] 1997 essay. He has mentored scores of young journalists, served as a board member on the National Association of Black Journalists and Unity Journalists of Color, and lectured at numerous universities.

“At the Forward, the nation’s oldest and leading Jewish journalism outlet, Washington will write an opinion column, develop and host an interview show, help recruit diverse contributors, interns and staff. . . .”

‘Is My Fellow Congressman Trying to Kill Me?’

April 18, 2021

From a Member, What Disinformation Has Wrought

Homepage photo: Washington Post

Support Journal-isms

Sixty people were on the Zoom call, and another 58 watched on Facebook Live. (Credit: Rebecca Aguilar)

From a Member, What Disinformation Wrought

How would you like to go to work every day wondering whether your colleagues were in on a plot to kill you?

That’s the situation Delegate Stacey Plaskett of the U.S. Virgin Islands, a member of Congress and a House impeachment manager in January, says she and others at her workplace face. Her words have resonance as the nation Friday marked the 100th-day anniversary of the Jan. 6 insurrection, and the continuing clamor by Republicans for “bipartisanship” in the Democratic-controlled Congress.

“Right now, there’s even a philosophical question among members of ‘do I want to have my name on legislation with someone who’s a liar?” Plaskett told the Journal-isms Roundtable, convened March 21 to discuss the ramifications for journalists of disinformation, “who is someone who I believe was trying to kill me two months ago, because they were spreading lies, or who is a seditionist in my belief, or someone who wants to overthrow our government? 

“So I know, in my office, you know, I’m considered a moderate . . . much more moderate than many of my Democratic colleagues, and I have a list of legislation that I previously co-sponsored with Republicans that I’ve told my leg’ [legislative] team, ‘hold off, because I have to come to grips with the notion that I’m actually going to work with that person, who previously, I may have had lunch with, who our daughters were pen pals. And now this joker, after the insurrection, still voted to object to the certification.

“So . . . I can’t just bring myself to even work on a piece of legislation with this person. And I’m considered a moderate, so I can’t even imagine what is happening in the minds of some of my more progressive left-of-myself members of Congress. It makes it really difficult.”

Virgin Islands Del. Stacey Plaskett, speaking via Zoom from St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands, tells the Journal-isms Roundtable that then-Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., was the target of disinformation about her record as a prosecutor during the Democratic primary last year. “And what was also frustrating was finding journalists who latched on to that and attempted to, you know, make news based on something that was based on misinformation,” Plaskett said. On Saturday, Niviane Petit Phelps, a Miami nurse, was arrested and accused of making threats against now-Vice President Harris. “Don’t punish her … ’cause she listened to what people tell her,” Phelps’ mother pleaded. (Credit: Sharon Farmer/sfphotoworks)

Who are the worst offenders? Plaskett was asked. 

“Oh, I don’t want to say that,” she replied. But Plaskett said she could “do like, maybe . . . four hands with a group that, you know, I’m definitely not breaking any bread with, and at least 10 or a dozen that I probably wouldn’t even get into an elevator with at this point. That’s how stark and how tense it is right now.”

Plaskett has reason to be worried. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has warned that if any Republican members of the House had aided the rioters as they sought to advance former president Donald Trump’s effort to overturn the election results, they would be punished.

A total of 139 House Republicans objected to certifying election results in certain states during the counting of Electoral College votes on Jan. 6, which was interrupted by a mob of Trump supporters who stormed the Capitol. They spread disinformation — that the election was “stolen.”

While members of Congress like Plaskett are victims of what’s now called the Big Lie, so are journalists. Rep. Ted Lieu, another of the impeachment managers, said in February that the media are among the enablers of Trumpism. Right-wing media paint an alternate view of reality. Trump voters accept it. They turn on any Republican who tries to deviate from that. Hence, Republicans stick with the Trump line. It makes it harder for journalists who seek the truth to be believed.

As Marty Baron prepared to retire as editor of The Washington Post at the end of February, he cited disinformation as the biggest threat to trust in journalism and to democracy. Disinformation affects not only the political arena, but the life-and-death responses to the COVID pandemic.

So what can journalists do about it? One step is to be smart about how disinformation is concocted, Al Tompkins of the Poynter Institute told the 60 who were on the Zoom call, and another 58 on Facebook Live. The recording can be viewed on YouTube.

Despite appearances, Oprah Winfrey and former president Barack Obama are actually time zones apart. Tompkins said, “It’s important for us to ask, not just what did I see? But what didn’t I understand about what I saw? Because technology is going to make it so much more difficult in the future.” (Credit: Sharon Farmer/sfphotoworks)

We knew about Photoshop, but not so much about more recent technology. Tompkins showed a shot of Oprah Winfrey seated in front of a fireplace, across from former president Barack Obama. Winfrey was in Santa Barbara, Calif., and Obama was in Washington, but the viewer would think they were in the same room. Tompkins also displayed a widely circulated video of Pelosi seemingly slurring her words. Then he demonstrated how an Adobe Premiere editing machine allows the user to manipulate the pitch of the speaker’s voice and the speed of the delivery.

The Adobe also enables the user to remove or add elements of a photo or video at will, to create whatever impression he or she wants to the viewer. The user can zap a person out of the photo or add a bush where there was none. It’s called a “content aware fill,” and “there is no journalistic use of that, that I would defend . . . But once it’s out there, then people can use it for anything,” Tompkins said.

Some of the remedies go to journalistic practices, such as the “truth sandwich” and the “liar’s dividend.” 

As the News Literacy Project has said, “Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society lays out the basics of how to correct the record, whether you’re an individual or a news outlet: Begin and conclude with the correct information, sandwiching the wrong information between. As Berkman puts it, ‘Make the truth, not the falsehood, the most vivid take-away.’

“That’s because repeated information sticks with us, whether the information is accurate or not. We rely on repetition. The more something is heard, the more it’s believed.”

Mike Webb (pictured) senior vice president of communications of the News Literacy Project, also spoke. It was four days before Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp signed that state’s restrictive voting laws.

“We issued a statement calling on state legislatures to base any changes that they’re making to their election laws on facts, because we’ve seen this rash of information or a rash of proposed legislation that is supposed to fix some of the election problems, but they’re based on the fiction that there were all these problems in the past election. And so . . . I think it’s very important for the journalists here to sort of share that reasoning with their audience and make sure that they understand these laws are being proposed to fix X, Y, and Z. But are they being proposed to fix something that’s not broken?”

In Georgia, at least, the project’s call seemed unsuccessful.

Webb said that while journalists might think that “when we write these things down, and we inform our audiences, that they’ll accept that and that they’ll act on that, because it’s factual, verified information. But I think what we have to remember are people are in filter bubbles, and that there’s a belonging for people.

“So there was a study recently that showed that people, even if they knew something was factually inaccurate, if it’s what their filter bubble believed, they would pass it along on their social channels. And so you have to really be aware that part of what you’re doing is trying to break that bubble. . . . And it’s very tough to crack that, because it’s an emotional belonging thing.”

Al Tompkins, senior faculty for broadcast and online at the Poynter Institute, said, “I wanted to show you some new tools that are making their way into the disinformation world right now. And it’s going to make your job, our job as journalists, unbelievably more difficult.” (Credit: Sharon Farmer/sfphotoworks)

Tompkins raised another issue: “To what extent do journalists make it difficult for elected officials to change their mind on important issues? How much would they fear being labeled a flip-flopper, so they dig in on illogical or unsupported views?”

The journalists on the call were riveted. “So besides going to credible sources and reporting on facts and the truth, a journalist’s job now includes detecting, decoding and publicly explaining the lies?” asked Ivan Roman, a former executive director of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists. “That’s something we all did and do in the reporting process, but now, given today’s dynamics, we have to publicly report on the lies also. That’s a normal part of the story now, correct? Does this mean that, unfortunately, we are giving more oxygen to the lies?”

“For me,” said Hazel Trice Edney, who runs the Trice Edney Wire news service, “this is an encouragement to — increasingly and wherever possible — resort to good old-fashioned shoe leather reporting. In other words, whenever possible, depend on your own photos, interviews, research and accuracy.”

“People are learning how to manipulate audio, images and video because all the ‘how-to’s’ are on YouTube,” Rebecca Aguilar (pictured), president-elect of the Society of Professional Journalists, wrote in the chat room.

Clockwise, from top, left, Monica R. Richardson, executive editor, Miami Herald/El Nuevo Herald and Florida regional editor at McClatchy; Karen Dunlap, president emerita of the Poynter Institute, and the News Literacy Project’s Mike Webb, senior vice president of communication. (Credit: Sharon Farmer/sfphotoworks)

Monica R. Richardson, who became executive editor of the Miami Herald on Jan. 1, also spoke of the need for journalists to go back to basics. “The most important thing Al said was go to the source. Look it up. Ask the question. And as simple as that seems, I think sometimes we realize we have to sacrifice things. We have to sacrifice being first on a story. We may have to make other sacrifices to making sure that we can go back to the basics and get people the information they need in a credible way.”

The Herald recently started working with a company called Subtext, she said. That’s a subscription messaging platform that allows organizations to text with their audiences, as a way to answers reader questions about the virus,” as Nieman Lab described it — without the “anything goes, true or not” environment of social media.

More than 500,000 people are subscribed to at least one of 600 hosts using Subtext, Nieman Lab’s Hanaa’ Tameez wrote in February. 

It’s “like having a two way conversation — what is the question you have about COVID? And that is a credible relationship that we have with someone . . . a way of using technology to do one-on-one with someone who has a question. 

“They type in a question and Google How do I blah, blah, blah, how do I find information about the vaccine? How do I get this effective vaccine? What do I know? But if we are able to establish and use tools that give us a direct relationship to have those conversations, I think . . .it makes it more powerful for us. . . . ” 

“Disinformation blends into the crowded media landscape around election time,” Miami Herald reporter Sarah Blaskey said in October. “It’s not always easy to spot. Investigative journalism is about shedding light and separating truth from lies. That’s what the Decoder is all about.”

In addition, Richardson noted that last fall, the Herald launched what it called an Election Ad Decoder. A Herald story then said, “By searching the Herald’s Election Ad Decoder, you can find out who paid for an ad, whether it contains false or misleading content, what data is being collected from you and where your money will go if you give. The Herald also worked extensively with academic experts to identify disinformation, hateful speech, foreign interference and content that promotes violence — flagging ads as such when they could jeopardize the integrity of the election.”

As the Roundtable is based in the District of Columbia,  Plaskett was asked about D.C. statehood, now a live issue in Congress. She expanded the question to include the Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico.

“It’s kind of like a chicken-and-egg question,” she said of the Virgin Islands. “In a lot of ways people would say, ‘Well, you know, you’re really a small in terms of population, your economy has not grown in such a way that would allow you to seem like you’re mature enough to be a state.’ But are we that way because of the status that we’re in, because we are a colony, because we have not been given the support necessary to grow ourselves into being at a position where we can be states, right? 

“You look at . . . from the Northwest Ordinance prior to that, every place that was considered a territory, the understanding was that eventually they would be a state. And the federal government gave such financial support and economic stimulus to those areas so that they would find themselves in a position to be a state, whether that’s bringing, you know, the Homestead Act, making it feasible for individuals to come there and farm or creating incentives for businesses to be there. . . .”

Plaskett also said, “Of course, we’re very interested in the District of Columbia being a state. I am actually for Puerto Rico statehood. And as the Virgin Islands in two years, we will be at our 175th year from emancipation of the U.S. Virgin Islands. The U.S. Virgin Islands and Haiti are the only two places in the Western Hemisphere that obtained their freedom from chattel slavery through organized, open rebellion, from violent overthrow.

“And so we count that date as very, very sacred to us. It’s July 3, interestingly, and so there’s been a question in our local legislature, myself and the governor, that we need to put that question out to our residents and to the people of the Virgin Islands, to determine if what they want our status to be moving forward.”

The delegate then panned her Zoom camera to the inviting blue waters surrounding St. John, prompting attendees to re-evaluate their vacation plans. 

“You need to be beating it on down to one of the prettiest islands you’ll ever find,” said Fred Sweets, veteran photojournalist now with the St. Louis American.


The Roundtable began with introductions to Babee Garcia (pictured), board member and director of digital strategy and content for Military Veterans in Journalism, a group that just launched in 2019.

“We are just trying to expand our community making sure that we are presenting opportunities for women, veterans who are interested in journalism, veterans of color, military spouses,” she said. The group’s material declares, “About 7.6 percent of Americans have served in the armed forces. Yet, just two percent of American media personnel are vets.”

In addition, we met Anthony D. Coley, one of several new African American officials at the Justice Department, who is in charge of public affairs. “There are a lot of issues that a lot of people care about. Criminal justice reform is at the top of the list.  Civil rights matters of at the top of the list,” Coley said, offering to return with other Justice Department officials.

Support Journal-isms

 

To subscribe at no cost, please send an email to journal-isms+subscribe@groups.io and say who you are.

Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.

Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor

Richard Prince’s Journal-isms originates from Washington. It began in print before most of us knew what the internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a “column.” Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity. Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince at journal-isms+owner@groups.io

About Richard Prince

View previous columns (after Feb. 13, 2016).

View previous columns (before Feb. 13, 2016)

Related posts

‘Black Journalists Only, Please’

richard

Alcindor Is NABJ’s Journalist of Year

richard

Journalists Say They Foresaw Tragic Outcome

richard

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.