Articles Feature

Lessons From the Fall of O’Reilly

by richard11925

Woman Called ‘Hot Chocolate’ Identifies Herself

Cecilia Alvear, Former NAHJ President, Dies at 77

White Men ‘Overwhelming’ on Cable Morning Shows

TV One Expanding ‘NewsOne Now’ to Two Hours

FCC Vote Leads to More Media Consolidation

NPR Reports Scant Progress on Diversity Figures

6 ‘Rhoden Fellows’ Named at the Undefeated

Census Tests More Hispanic-Friendly Questions

Short Takes

The women's advocacy group UltraViolet protests outside Fox News headquarters in New York this week. (Credit: UltraViolet)
The women’s advocacy group UltraViolet protests outside Fox News headquarters in New York this week. (Credit: UltraViolet)

Woman Called ‘Hot Chocolate’ Identifies Herself

Perquita Burgess, who said Bill O’Reilly called her “Hot Chocolate” as they worked together, and Rashad Robinson, executive director of the civil rights group Color of Change, were among those credited Thursday and Friday with forcing the decision to oust the Fox News host amid sexual harassment allegations.

The attention of pundits, editorial writers and others, however, shifted toward the broader issues of how much meaningful change would take place at Fox News (not much, many said), how O’Reilly’s comeuppance would affect sexual harassment in the workplace (one can always hope), comparisons with the behavior of President Trump and the implications for other conservative media figures.

“The departure of O’Reilly — like the departure, last summer, of [Fox CEO Roger] Ailes — suggests that the network’s old way of operating has become unsustainable,” Kelefa Sanneh wrote Thursday in the New Yorker.

Perquita Burgess appears on "The View."
Perquita Burgess, right, appears on “The View.”

But Janine Jackson of Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting wrote Friday, “There’s no reason to believe that culture has changed, particularly as the network won’t make the results of their investigation public. . . .”

Susan Chira wrote Thursday in the New York Times, “Judging from more than 950 comments posted on Facebook after The New York Times asked women for their assessment of Mr. O’Reilly’s departure, many doubted that this heralded a new era for Fox or would encourage more women to report sexual harassment. . . .”

Burgess’ identity was kept secret until she appeared Thursday on ABC’s “The View.”

“Burgess was a temp worker at Fox News when, she said, O’Reilly sexually harassed her,” Stephen Proctor reported Thursday for Superfan TV. “According to Burgess, the harassment included his grunting at her and leering at her, as well as O’Reilly making inappropriate comments, at least one of which went beyond sexual harassment.

“ ‘I’m just sitting there minding my business and he walks past and says, “Hey, Hot Chocolate.” But he didn’t look at me when he said it. And I didn’t respond. I was mortified because not only was it sexual, I took that as a very plantation remark,’ Burgess said of one incident.

“Burgess didn’t file a complaint against O’Reilly at Fox because she wasn’t technically an employee. Nor did she file a complaint with her temp agency, which had a lot of people working at Fox, because she didn’t want to damage the agency’s relationship with Fox. But she did take to Twitter in both 2010 and 2014 expressing her feelings toward O’Reilly in no uncertain terms. . . .”

Zahara Hill reported for Huffington Post Black Voices Thursday that in March 2015, Color of Change “began an advertising boycott urging companies to pull ads airing during ‘The O’Reilly Factor.‘ The campaign, which fluctuated in momentum throughout its first two years, gained traction last month after O’Reilly inappropriately remarked that Congresswoman Maxine Waters’ hair looked like a wig that the late James Brown would sport. . . .”

Writing in the Chicago Tribune Thursday, Mary Schmich listed nine lessons from the fall of O’Reilly, who was reported to be receiving a payoff of as much as $25 million:

“1. Change doesn’t grow in silence. . . 

“2. Money talks when money walks. . . .

“3. Even when they behave badly, the rich tend to get richer. . . .

“4. The end of O’Reilly on Fox isn’t the end of misogyny. . . .

“5. Can we stop lumping all old white guys, sometimes known as middle-age white guys, together? . . .

“6. Sexism goes beyond sexual harassment. . . .

“7. As long as men hold most of the power, there will be women who defend sexist men. . . .

“8. Almost every woman has a story, probably more than one, of being sexually harassed. . . .

“9. All power is borrowed and can be revoked at any moment. . . .”

The response of some fellow conservatives was perhaps unforeseen. Writing in the National Review, David French declared on Thursday:

“There are those who say that the Left is ‘taking scalps,’ and they have a list of Republican victims to prove their thesis. Roger Ailes is out at Fox News. Bill O’Reilly is out at Fox News. Michael Flynn is out at the White House. Those three names — the head of the most powerful cable news network, the highest-rated cable news personality, and the national-security adviser — represent a stunning wave of resignations and terminations.

“But this isn’t scalp-taking, it’s scalp-giving. Time and again prominent conservative personalities have failed to uphold basic standards of morality or even decency. Time and again the conservative public has rallied around them, seeking to protect their own against the wrath of a vengeful Left. Time and again the defense has proved unsustainable as the sheer weight of the facts buries the accused.

“Moreover, the pattern is repeating itself with the younger generation of conservative celebrities. The sharp rise and meteoric fall of both Tomi [Lahren] and Milo Yiannopoulos were driven by much the same dynamic that sustained O’Reilly for years, even in the face of previous sexual-harassment complaints — Lahren and Yiannopoulos were ‘fighters’ who ‘tell it like it is.’ O’Reilly was the master of the ‘no-spin zone’ and seemed fearless in taking on his enemies.

“What followed was a toxic culture of conservative celebrity, where the public elevated personalities more because of their pugnaciousness than anything else. . . .”

Cecilia Alvear, Former NAHJ President, Dies at 77

Cecilia Alvear
Cecilia Alvear

“Cecilia Alvear, a longtime television journalist and former president of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists who crusaded for greater opportunities for young Latino journalists throughout her career, died Friday at her home in Santa Monica after battling breast cancer,” Sonali Kohli reported for the Los Angeles Times. “She was 77.

“Alvear had bounced around local Los Angeles news stations until 1982, when NBC hired her to run its Mexico City bureau. She remained at the network until her retirement in 2007.

“During that time Alvear covered wars and revolutions in El Salvador and Nicaragua, and produced multiple interviews with Cuban President Fidel Castro, said George Lewis, her partner of 23 years. . . .”

Veronica Villafañe wrote for her Media Moves site, “She was a dedicated journalist, a champion for diversity, and a socially-conscious individual whose generosity of spirit made her a selfless and incredible friend. Her death is a great loss for those who knew and loved her and for those whose path she helped pave.

“Cecilia was a pioneer who helped open the door for many Latina journalists. . . .”

“For years, she actively pushed for more diversity in newsrooms, additionally serving on the boards of UNITY-Journalists of Color and the Nieman foundation. . . .”

Credit: Media Matters for America
Credit: Media Matters for America

White Men ‘Overwhelming’ on Cable Morning Shows

“A Media Matters analysis of morning shows on cable news networks from January 1 to March 31 found that white men make up an overwhelming percentage of guest appearances on CNN, Fox News, and MSNBC’s morning shows,” Cristina López G. reported Friday for Media Matters for America.

“The study found that black, Latino, Asian-American and Middle Eastern voices are critically underrepresented, and women make up only a quarter of guest appearances. . . .”

TV One Expanding ‘NewsOne Now’ to Two Hours

Roland Martin
Roland S. Martin

Beginning in the third quarter of this year, “TV One will enhance its live morning news, current affairs and lifestyle programming by expanding to three hours of live television,” the network announced, “beginning with an expanded version of [NewsOne] Now, hosted by Roland S. Martin, from 7-9 am ET.

“Later this year, the show will undergo a name and format change to complement the increased time slot to become Black America Today, the only daily news show that covers the issues that matter to the African American community.

“ ‘After six consecutive quarters of growth for [NewsOne] Now, we are excited to announce that Roland Martin will continue to be a voice to the African American community with more time to share the news and stories that matter most to the Black community,’ said D’Angela Proctor, TV One’s SVP, Original Programming and Production.

” ‘Viewers can look forward to more coverage of the latest headlines in addition to lifestyle stories in the areas of entertainment, business, personal finance, health and inspiration.’

“The third hour will become home to a brand new live, multi-platform one-hour daily talk show that is fun, informative, engaging and live. Hosted by a panel of four women who are dynamic, smart, funny and opinionated, they want to empower and inspire African American women to tackle the challenges of their everyday lives. (A show-specific announcement will follow shortly).

“TV One will also focus on expanding its popular True Crime & Justice programming, which has become a staple for the network on Monday nights. Beginning in August 2017, a second night of true crime shows will premiere, anchored by the proven series For My Man (Season 3). . . .”

FCC Vote Leads to More Media Consolidation

“In a move that is expected to trigger another wave of station consolidation, the FCC today voted to allow station groups to exceed the nominal ownership cap that limits groups to coverage of no more than 39% of U.S. TV homes,” Harry A. Jessell reported Thursday for TVNewsCheck.

On Friday, Jessell reported that the Sinclair Broadcast Group “announced the acquisition of 14 stations in eight markets from Bonten Media for $240 million.”

Lorraine Mirabella added Friday in the Baltimore Sun, “Bonten owns 14 television stations in eight markets, which reach about 1 percent of the TV households in the United States. The broadcaster also operates four stations through ‘joint sales agreements‘ with Esteem Broadcasting, and those stations will be acquired by Sinclair-owned Cunningham Broadcasting.

“. . . The acquisition will help Sinclair expand its regional presence in several states where it already owns stations, Chris Ripley, Sinclair president and CEO, said in Friday’s announcement. Sinclair owns, operates or offers service to 173 television stations in 81 markets.

Mirabella also noted, “Bloomberg News has reported that Sinclair is preparing to buy Tribune Media, which would bring together two of the nation’s largest television station owners. . . .”

The National Hispanic Media Coalition was among the opponents of the FCC decision.

Carmen Scurato
Carmen Scurato

Carmen Scurato, the coalition’s director of policy and legal affairs, said in a statement, “Fewer than 10 percent of broadcast licenses are held by people of color at a time when over a third of Americans are people of color. That doesn’t happen by accident, that happens when policy makers bend the rules for media conglomerates to continue to amass greater power over what we see and hear.

“Our last resort is accountability and the FCC today has again chipped away at broadcast requirements that would give the public any glimpse at why platforms owned by women and people of color are disappearing. The FCC must find more ways for the public to access timely data and analysis on media diversity with a meaningful opportunity to weigh in on these distressing changes.”

Separately, the Multicultural Media, Telecom and Internet Council called attention Friday to a landmark in civil rights history: the April 24, 1967, United Church of Christ petition asking the FCC to adopt a rule barring race and gender discrimination in broadcast station employment.

The MMTC asked the FCC “to complete the journey UCC began in 1967 by completing the long-dormant EEO rulemaking and restoring strong broadcast EEO enforcement. . . .”

WBUR-FM in Boston, an NPR affiliate, recruited at the career fair last year at the joint convention of the National Association of Black Journalists and the National Association of Hispanic Journalists. (Credit: scoopeasy)
WBUR-FM in Boston, an NPR affiliate, recruited at the career fair last year at the joint convention of the National Association of Black Journalists and the National Association of Hispanic Journalists. (Credit: scoopeasy)

NPR Reports Scant Progress on Diversity Figures

“Increasing the racial and ethnic diversity of NPR’s newsroom staff is a publicly acknowledged priority from top management on down,” NPR ombudsman Elizabeth Jensen reported on Friday. “But in 2016, NPR made virtually no progress in changing the makeup of its staff.

“According to NPR’s human resources department, of the 350 employees in the news division as of Oct. 31, 2016, 75.4 percent were white. Asians made up 8.3 percent of the staff, followed by blacks or African-Americans (8.0 percent), Hispanics or Latinos (5.4 percent), those who identified as two or more races or ethnic identities (2.6 percent) and American Indian (0.3 percent).

“(Because this column was delayed, we also asked for the most current figures, as of March 31, 2017, which are included at the end of the column and are only slightly different.)

“The Ombudsman’s office has been tracking these numbers for several years; the comparisons with previous years can be seen in the accompanying charts. Essentially, they show that the numbers changed little, or at least they changed incrementally, in the past five years. There’s simply no way around it: If the goal is to increase diversity in the newsroom, last year’s was a disappointing showing. It also mirrors a national trend; newsroom diversity has ‘nearly flatlined‘ for more than a decade, reports Farai Chideya, in the Columbia Journalism Review. . . .”

Jensen also wrote, “Some in the newsroom and upper management at NPR argued that the focus on the raw numbers discounts other changes last year that had the effect of contributing to NPR sounding more diverse on-air. . . . Although not publicly visible, the hiring process has also changed in the past year; most job candidate pools now include diverse candidates, unlike in the past, argued Keith Woods, NPR’s vice president for newsroom training and diversity.

“Far more people I spoke to in the newsroom expressed frustration — some even said they were angry — at the slow pace of change. ‘The company has been talking about the importance of diversity for many, many years,’ but changes are not happening, said Marisa Peñaloza, a senior producer on NPR’s National Desk.

“That’s despite a number of meetings in the past year between NPR’s senior management and a group of Hispanic employees, as well as a concerted recruiting push at last August’s joint conference of the National Association of Black Journalists and the National Association of Hispanic Journalists. . . .”

6 ‘Rhoden Fellows’ Named at the Undefeated

William C. Rhoden
William C. Rhoden

“Bill Rhoden is frustrated. He doesn’t hold back,” Ed Sherman wrote Thursday for the Poynter Institute.

“ ‘Our industry (sports media) is one of the most segregated parts of journalism,’ Rhoden said.

“Later, he said, ‘If you’re an editor, and you don’t have any Black reporters, you’re part of the problem.’

“Rhoden, a 35-year veteran, wants to change a dynamic that still shows few African-Americans writing about sports and even fewer in positions of leadership in the sports department. The Undefeated, ESPN’s multiplatform initiative for sports, race and culture, is giving him the chance by sponsoring the Rhoden Fellows.

“It is a sports journalism internship program focused on identifying and training aspiring African-American journalists from Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). The inaugural class, announced in March, has six journalists.

“With Rhoden and others serving as hands-on mentors, the students will contribute stories to The Undefeated during the school year, and they will have paid internships in the summer, working in New York, Washington, D.C. and Bristol, Conn. . . .”

As announced March 8, the fellows are Miniya Shabazz, Grambling State University; Kyla Wright, Hampton University; Paul A. Holston, Howard University; C. Isaiah Smalls II, Morehouse College; Simone Benson, Morgan State University; and Donovan Dooley, North Carolina A&T University.

Census Tests More Hispanic-Friendly Questions

“Federal officials are considering major changes in how they ask Americans about their race and ethnicity, with the goal of producing more accurate and reliable data in the 2020 census and beyond,” D’Vera Cohn reported Thursday for the Pew Research Center.

“Recently released Census Bureau research underscores an important reason why: Many Hispanics, who are the nation’s largest minority group, do not identify with the current racial categories.

“Census officials say this is a problem because in order to obtain good data, they need to make sure people can match themselves to the choices they are offered. Census data on race and Hispanic origin are used to redraw congressional district boundaries and enforce voting and other civil rights laws, as well as in a wide variety of research, including Pew Research Center studies.

“After years of trying to persuade Hispanics to choose a standard race category, the Census Bureau has been testing a new approach, with what the agency says are promising results. In 2015, the bureau contacted 1.2 million U.S. households for a test census that experimented with two different ways of combining the Hispanic and race questions into one question (and included a proposed new ‘Middle Eastern or North African’ category as well). Respondents could self-identify in as many categories as they wanted, or only one.

“The result: More than 70% of self-identified Hispanics said they were Hispanic but did not choose a race in answering the combined question, and less than 1% checked the ‘some other race’ box on the test census. . . .”

Short Takes

Support Journal-isms

Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.

Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor

Richard Prince’s Journal-isms originates from Washington. It began in print before most of us knew what the internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a “column.” Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity.
Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince at journal-isms-owner@yahoogroups.com

To be notified of new columns, contact journal-isms-subscribe@yahoogroups.com and tell us who you are.

Related posts

Celebrating Induction of Metro Seven into NABJ Hall of Fame

richard

Detroit Free Press’ Stephen Henderson Out After Harassment Investigation

richard

First Amendment Not for Whites Only

richard

1 comment

Gregg Morris April 22, 2017 at 11:56 am

I remember long, long ago as O’Reilly’s popularity was beginning, when I started a working relationship/project with The Center for Communications, Inc., which scheduled at Hunter the creme da la creme of journalism and media panelists for events at about journalism and media, the Center was excited about bringing O’Reilly to campus. After I watched two of his shows, I said, politely, of course, not on this campus with has a reputation of being the most culturally diverse four-year CUNY college. I was surprised that their fascination ignore how despicable he was even then.

Anyway,O’Reilly and what he represents and what he did will result in him getting another “news” position but probably for only a few hundred thousand $$$ a year. He will, I bet, being show up as a guest on news shows, mainstream corporate like CNN. Dealing with sexual predation in the news business by buying out the predators with millions and millions of $$$ tells our moms, sisters, daughters and female friends and neighbors that they really don’t count and that the North Pole will melt before that kind of bigotry is eradicated.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.