Herald Publisher Meets With J-Groups
Why Do Journalists of Color Leave? Here’s a Start
Latinos Missing as Debate Moderators — Again
. . . And That’s the Way It Was
Reporter Disputes Violent Image of Portland
Pro-Police Readers Protest Two Cartoons
Some Relate to Kenosha Editor Who Quit
Student Station Manager Urged to Quit Over Tweet
More Prisons Blocking Media From Access
Lopez, San Martin Vie for NAHJ Presidency
Joy Reid Phrase About Muslims Creates Tempest
Short Takes
Support Journal-ismsHerald Publisher Meets With J-Groups
The publisher of the Miami Herald is in discussions with Black and Hispanic journalists associations and the Society of Professional Journalists over comments about race by Cuban-American sportswriter Armando Salguero that the National Association of Black Journalists calls “disturbing and unacceptable.”
A meeting by Zoom took place Friday, NABJ President Dorothy Tucker told Journal-isms. “Let me confirm it was a productive meeting but it’s clear we need to meet again and we will,” she added.
Tucker said in a statement earlier this week, “I am concerned a columnist who feels it’s ok to insult the Black community may work in a newsroom where Black people are not valued and Black journalists are not respected. Unacceptable.”
The controversy is the latest to test the boundaries of opinion writers’ license to express their thoughts free of recrimination. Mindy Marques (pictured), publisher and executive editor of the Herald, originally defended Salguero, tweeting, “The right to free expression and a free press are foundational to our democracy. @ArmandoSalguero is a @MiamiHerald sports columnist and unlike reporters, columnists have broad latitude to express their opinions. Those opinions do not reflect the views of the Miami Herald.”
But Marques tweeted the next day, Aug. 29, “His comments were uninformed, insensitive and deeply troubling. For that, we apologize. We expect our columnists to base their opinions on reporting and facts. We are addressing this matter internally.
“To be clear, @ArmandoSalguero’s tweets do not reflect the views or values of the Miami Herald,” she added.
In 2017, Sports Illustrated named Salguero one of “the 30 Most Influential Hispanics in Sports.”
Joshua Ceballos reported for Miami New Times, “In November 2016, after confronting San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick during a conference call before a matchup between the visiting 49ers and the Miami Dolphins, Salguero wrote a column deeming Kaepernick a ‘fraud’ and an ‘unrepentant hypocrite’ for wearing a T-shirt that depicted a 1960 meeting between Fidel Castro and Malcolm X.
“Last year, as New Times reported, Salguero tweeted that he would ‘rather have Satan’ as a quarterback than Kaepernick, who had been blacklisted by the NFL for kneeling during the national anthem to protest social injustice. . . .”
Suzanne Gamboa wrote Tuesday for NBC News, Salguero “posted a tweet Friday with video of Tennessee Titans safety Kevin Byard and quarterback Ryan Tannehill, explaining that the athletes sat out their practice as a show of solidarity against police violence and racial injustice.
“In the video, Tannehill said that ‘this country is founded upon racist ideas with slaves being brought here from the day of foundation.’
“Salguero lashed out at Tannehill, paraphrasing him as saying the United States of America was founded upon racist ideas.
“ ‘I am so sick of the America bashing by people who have never lived and would never live anywhere else,’ Salguero said in his tweet.
“Salguero was born in Cuba and has written about his escape from Cuba under Fidel Castro.
“The comment drew criticism on Twitter over several days, with some critics digging up previous statements and comments by Salguero, including verbal clashes with Colin Kaepernick.
“When asked to comment on the situation on Tuesday, Salguero referred to a statement he made on Twitter over the weekend: ‘Racism, in all its forms, is disgusting, wrong and an anathema to every fiber of my being as both an American and a Christian…’
“He said he does not deny the truth about ongoing racism or ‘that slavery has been a stain on this entire Earth … So if anyone who sincerely interpreted my comments to suggest otherwise, I assure you that is not what I’m about and it was not my intent to cause anyone pain.’ . . .”
Of her talks with NABJ, Marques messaged Journal-isms Friday, “We have had two productive conversations and will continue the discussion.” She tweeted, “Thanks @Dorothy4NABJ for a candid conversation this morning. We welcome the invitation from @NABJ to discuss diversity issues @Miami Herald and collaborate with @SFBJA @SPJFla and @NAHJSouthFl. We are listening.”
The NABJ statement, issued Tuesday, said, “Although Salguero has since expressed regret for the tweet, the problems at the Miami Herald appear to be much broader than one writer. NABJ supports the efforts and demands of the One Herald Guild, representing many of the employees, calling for immediate systemic actions from the Miami Herald to address a myriad of diversity issues.”
The controversy swept up other Herald staffers, Ceballos reported Tuesday for Miami New Times. “Yesterday, after the paper’s management censored a portion of a fellow columnist’s podcast in which he addressed the controversy, the Herald attracted even more condemnation and claims of hypocrisy, leading some newsroom employees to criticize their bosses and ask for more racial sensitivity. . . .
“Greg Cote (pictured), himself a Herald sportswriter, recorded an episode for his Herald podcast that included commentary about the situation. But before the episode was released Monday morning, those six minutes of the show were cut out by the paper’s management. . . .”
The One Herald Guild tweeted Tuesday, ” One thing we know is that racism isn’t an opinion. It should not be excused, and it has no place at the Miami Herald + el Nuevo Herald.”
The Guild also tweeted, “Among our proposals, we’re asking management to create a framework for the resolution of future conflicts by immediately adopting, in the form of a memo of understanding, a comprehensive anti-racism policy that repairs harm through deliberate conversation & thoughtful education.”
The South Florida chapter of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists messaged on Facebook Wednesday, “We are closely monitoring the situation at the Miami Herald. In partnership with SPJ Florida & NABJ-SFL, we are in discussions with employees & management at the newspaper & will report our findings.
“For now, we’ll leave you with this: our groups condemn racism and censorship.”
The progressive group Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting has observed, “The issue of columns and truthfulness has become an issue of late, with the New York Times recently letting go editorial page editor James Bennet for not checking out an incendiary column he ran from Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas).”
- Tim Padgett, WLRN-FM, Miami: Herald Columnist’s Racist Tweets Reflect South Florida Latinos’ Summer Of Denial
- Elle Reynolds, The Federalist: Miami Herald Defenestrates Cuban Sports Reporter For Criticizing White Millionaire QB
Why Do Journalists of Color Leave? Here’s a Start
An admittedly narrowly focused study has concluded that journalists of color leave the U.S. journalism industry “because ‘they decided to’ — not because they couldn’t find sufficient or any work; company downsizing, restructuring or buyout; nor retirement.” The study reframes “the newsroom/the industry as the problem — not ‘Leavers’ ‘ inability to ‘fit’ in nor a lack of training.”
Carla Murphy (pictured, below) wrote Aug. 26 for Source, an OpenNews project, “For three weeks this February-March, more than 100 ‘Leavers’ — 81% of whom were women of color and half of whom were Black — responded to an ethical and practical call to gather exit data to: ‘serve as a resource for current students and JOCs [journalists of color] who are making [career] decisions, often in isolation, in an industry in crisis’ and ‘help newsroom managers to improve the retention of JOCs, particularly, through mid-career.’ “
Murphy is a 2020-2021 visiting fellow in Boston College’s journalism program. She is also vice president and a board member of the Journalism & Women Symposium, known as JAWS. The project is “designed to amplify the impact of journalism code and the community of developers, designers, journalists, and editors who make it.”
“As a testament to the survey aims and design, and respondents’ commitment to journalism — the practice, less so, the industry — 83% agreed to participate in follow-up interviews and surveys related to this project, . . .” Murphy continued.
“The data corroborate whisper-network news and this project’s central hypothesis that JOCs leave at mid-career. (Most ‘Leavers’ left journalism because ‘they decided to’ — not because they couldn’t find sufficient or any work; company downsizing, restructuring or buyout; nor retirement.) Also of note, one-third of ‘Leavers’ say they had managerial duties at the time they left.
“This mid-career ‘leakage’ of experience, potential leadership and representation matters. It raises questions about the timing of diversity initiatives at the start of the career pipeline and their return on investment (ROI) for both the industry and communities that newsrooms serve. Proceeding along this line of inquiry re-frames the newsroom/the industry as the problem — not ‘Leavers’’ inability to ‘fit’ in nor a lack of training. . . .”
However, Murphy wrote this caution: “The ‘Leavers’ sample (n=101) may not be representative of JOCs leaving the U.S. journalism industry, and findings are applicable to the sample population, only. Do use the ‘Leavers’ profile and findings as a starting or supplemental point in discussions around the hiring and retention of JOCs in local, regional or national outlets and markets, and for informed discussion about career pathways. . . .”
- Rachel Belle, KIRO, Seattle: Black professionals want you to be an active advocate at work, not a passive ally
- Kristen Chick, Nieman Reports: Want Diverse Newsrooms? Unions Push for Pay Equity As a Path Forward
- Serena Cho, Columbia Journalism Review: College newsrooms challenge an industry’s status quo
- Letrell Deshan Crittenden and Andrea Wenzel, Columbia Journalism Review: For BIPOC communities, local news crisis extends beyond major cities
- Investigative Reporters & Editors: Journalist of Color Investigative Reporting Fellowship
- Layla A. Jones, Billy Penn: Inquirer journalists of color demand action on diversity and culture in public report card
- Marc Lacey, Nieman Reports: Journalists Need to Remember that Not All News Readers are White
- Dawn McMullan, International News Media Association: INMA, Google News Initiative launch Elevate Scholarships for under-represented groups in media
- Waubgeshig Rice, The Walrus, Canada: Letter to a Young Indigenous Journalist
- Hanna Ziady, CNN: Ben & Jerry’s is launching a podcast about white supremacy in America
NAHJ President Hugo Balta said, “When the people in the positions who sincerely inform 32 million eligible voters do not fulfill their responsibility, it is not a question to us as to why Latinos’ civic engagement is low . . . each election year.” (video)
Latinos Missing as Debate Moderators — Again
“The head of the National Assn. of Hispanic Journalists sent a harsh message to the Commission on Presidential Debates regarding the lack of a Latino moderator in the upcoming sanctioned face-offs between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden,” Stephen Battaglio reported Friday in the Los Angeles Times.
“NAHJ President Hugo Balta said in a video posted Wednesday night that the commission that sanctions the debates — expected to be watched by as many as 80 million TV viewers — is perpetuating the ‘erasure’ of Latinos by failing to represent them in the moderator choices announced earlier that day.
“ ‘Three white co-chairs of the Commission on Presidential Debates have once again denied Hispanics and Latinos a seat at the table approaching election 2020,’ Balta said.
” ‘It is preposterous to look at the state of our country and increasingly polarized communities across the nation and not be left to wonder how is it possible that our community remains excluded. When the people in the positions who sincerely inform 32 million eligible voters do not fulfill their responsibility, it is not a question to us as to why Latinos’ civic engagement is low . . . each election year.’
“The moderators announced for the debates are two white men, Chris Wallace of Fox News and Steve Scully of C-SPAN, and two women, Susan Page of USA Today and Kristen Welker of NBC News, who is Black. The first debate will be held Sept. 29 at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland. . . .”
Tom Jones added Thursday for the Poynter Institute, “Earlier this month, Rudy Giuliani, in a rather overwritten and much-too-long letter [PDF] that apparently represented the Trump campaign, gave the commission a list of 24 suggested moderators. The commission chose none of them. . . .
“But, an interesting note, Giuliani’s list did include ABC ‘World News Tonight’ anchor David Muir and ‘CBS Evening News’ anchor Norah O’Donnell, but it did not include “NBC Nightly News” anchor Lester Holt.”
Holt’s May 11, 2017, interview with Trump elicited the comment seen by many as an admission that when Trump fired FBI Director James Comey, Trump had in mind shutting down the investigation into his presidential campaign’s ties to Russia.
NAHJ also protested the lack of Latino moderators in 2016 and in 2012.
- Renée Graham, Boston Globe: Empathy and compassion for president
- Paul Greeley, TVNewsCheck: Entravision Helping Newly Naturalized Hispanic Americans To Vote
- Errol Louis, Daily News, New York: Donald Trump, affirmative action case (Aug. 27)
- Mary Mitchell, Chicago Sun-Times: Blacks for Trump more solidified this time around
- Askia Muhammad, Washington Informer: Biden Won’t Win
- Clarence Page, Chicago Tribune: Joe Biden’s familiar straight talk faces Donald Trump’s doublespeak
- Fabiola Santiago, Miami Herald: Trump isn’t our savior from socialism, Florida Latinos. He’s the ‘caudillo’ we fled
- Sakshi Venkatraman, NBC News: Ad calling out Trump for anti-Asian rhetoric will air in battleground states
. . . And That’s the Way It Was
Norah O’Donnell, anchor of the “CBS Evening News,” announced Wednesday that it was the 57th anniversary of the day the program went from 15 to 30 minutes. When the piece showed a photo of the staff, led by anchor Walter Cronkite, everyone appeared to be white.
Bill Plante, who covered the civil rights movement for CBS, messaged Journal-isms Thursday, “When I joined CBS News in New York in June, 1964 there was one Black reporter at New York headquarters – Ben Holman. He was not on the Evening News staff; he was what was then called a ‘reporter-assignment editor,’ as was I. I don’t recall there being any people of color on the Evening News staff, but I wasn’t working directly with them.
“Holman went on to a distinguished teaching career — here’s a link to the University of Maryland entry.
“I don’t know when Evening News was integrated, but I would guess that it was sometime in the later ‘60s or early ‘70s.
“That’s about the time CBS News began to hire some more Black reporters. I worked with Randy Daniels and Mike Dejoie.”
In an oral history for the late Wallace Terry’s “Missing Pages: Black Journalists of Modern America: An Oral History,” Holman said, “In October (1962) I joined WBBM, the CBS station. I was the first black on television news in Chicago.
“In January 1963, I got a call to come to New York to audition for the network. The other networks, not long before, had hired their first blacks — [Mal] Goode at ABC, Bob Teague at NBC. I guess CBS was catching up. I was made the first. Teague and I were on general assignment. Goode was posted at the U.N.”
Cronkite anchored the “CBS Evening News” for 19 years (1962–1981), was known as “the most trusted man in America” and closed each show with his signature “and that’s the way it is.”
Reporter Disputes Violent Image of Portland
President Trump and his supporters are successfully changing the subject from his poor leadership in the COVID-19 crisis and the racial reckoning prompted by police shootings of Black civilians to the need for “law and order” in cities with Democratic mayors, even threatening to cut their federal funding.
But a Portland, Ore., journalist cautions that the public is getting the wrong impression about the violence in his city.
“There are those who are portraying Portland as a city under siege and that is simply not true,” Jonathan Levinson (pictured) of Oregon Public Broadcasting messaged Journal-isms on Wednesday, repeating a caution he expressed on public radio’s “Here and Now” on Tuesday.
“The protests are isolated to a few blocks downtown around the Multnomah [C]ounty justice center and federal courthouse. On other nights they go to police precincts or other law enforcement affiliated buildings but they remain isolated to those few blocks around the building in question. On any given night, if you were out in the city, you’d likely have no idea anything was happening.”
The description is similar to what has happened in other cities where “rioting” has taken place. Local reporters have said that there were “pockets of rioting” in cities such as Baltimore in 2015, and that networks sometimes ran footage of the same building being attacked over and over, giving viewers the impression that the violence was more widespread than it was.
-
- Robin Abcarian, Los Angeles Times: White people will contort themselves to justify the police killing of Black people
-
- Jeff Asher and Tio Hardiman, “Here and Now,” WBUR-FM, Boston: President Trump Says Crime Is Rising In Democrat-Led Cities. That’s Only Half-True
-
- Nathalie Baptiste, Mother Jones: There Are No Black Victims in Donald Trump’s America
-
-
Jamelle Bouie, New York Times: Trump Needs His Own Sister Souljah Moment
-
-
- John Cassidy, New Yorker: Donald Trump’s Incitements to Violence Have Crossed an Alarming Threshold
- Sara Cline, Associated Press: Portland protests set up clash between journalists, police
-
- Elvia Diaz, Arizona Republic: If ‘guns don’t kill, people do,’ why aren’t gun advocates condemning armed vigilantes?
-
- Ryan Devereaux, The Intercept: The Thin Blue Line Between Violent, Pro-Trump Militias and Police (Aug. 28)
-
- Editorial, Democrat and Chronicle, Rochester, N.Y.: Daniel Prude shouldn’t have died. That’s why Rochester police need total reform
-
- Nick Gillespie, Reason: How Portland’s Protests Drifted into ‘Dangerous Territory’
-
- Matt Lewis, Daily Beast: Biden’s Leading, but Trump’s Still Calling the Tune
-
- Harry Litman, Los Angeles Times: Trump is our first pro-vigilante president. Now stop and think about what that means
-
- Julianne Malveaux, National Newspaper Publishers Association: America’s Mistreatment of Its Black Citizens
-
- Barbara McQuade, Chuck Rosenberg, Joyce Vance, Andrew Weissmann and Mimi Rocah, USA Today: Kenosha visit reality: Trump is anything but a ‘law and order’ leader
-
- Tyler Monroe, Media Matters for America: Fox News prime-time shows spent over 3 hours displaying violent imagery in August
-
- Sarah Olutola, Washington Post: The history of racist colonial violence can help us understand police violence
-
- Alice Speri, The Intercept: Can “Progressive” Prosecutors Bring Justice to Victims of Police Violence? (Aug. 27)
-
- Ray Suarez, Slate: Kenosha Police Already Had a Reputation
-
For some late night hilarity, read @PaightenHarkins first-hand account of the anti-Pat Bagley protest. Proud Boys, QAnons, MAGAs, RW militias … all present and accounted for.
Happy to be defined by those who find my work offensive 2/endhttps://t.co/ls19jxvC8A
— Pat Bagley (@Patbagley) September 4, 2020
Pro-Police Readers Protest Two Cartoons
A crowd of about 60 law enforcement supporters showed up Wednesday at the Salt Lake Tribune’s shared printing press to protest a Pat Bagley editorial cartoon that they said disrespects and endangers police, Paighten Harkins reported Thursday for the Tribune.
On the East Coast, meanwhile, a small group of demonstrators gathered outside the offices of The Daily Gazette in Schenectady, N.Y., Thursday to protest the publication of a syndicated cartoon. Police leaders, a town board and a congressional candidate joined in the criticism.
“The four-panel illustration by Chris Britt through Creators Syndicate was published in The Gazette on Monday,” John Cropley reported Wednesday for the Gazette. “It shows a beefy policeman blasting a Black man five times in the back with his service pistol while saying ‘You have the right to remain.’ The final panel shows the man lying on the ground, spattered with blood and five holes in his shirt, below the word ‘silent.’ “
In Salt Lake City, Harkins wrote that the Bagley cartoon “shows a police officer at a doctor’s office. The officer and physician are looking at an X-ray image, which shows a Ku Klux Klan member where the man’s spine and pelvis should be. The doctor tells the officer, whose mouth is agape, ‘Well, there’s your problem…’
“The rally — called ‘Back the Blue: Boycott Salt Lake Tribune!!’ — came together Wednesday after the Utah Sheriffs’ Association and the leader of Utah Business Revival, a group that has held a series of protests against coronavirus restrictions, condemned the drawing,” Harkins wrote.
“The Tribune does not plan to apologize, George Pyle, the editorial page editor, said, and the cartoon remains online. . . .”
Similarly, Gazette Editor Miles Reed addressed criticism Wednesday, saying, “We’re sorry that some readers were upset by the cartoon, but we felt it was a valid commentary on something very real that’s happening in America today.
“Communities all across the nation are having a moment of reckoning about racial injustice and all kinds of related issues. The most recent shootings in Wisconsin — and, more importantly, the aftermath — are part of that reckoning.”
Some Relate to Kenosha Editor Who Quit
Daniel J. Thompson (pictured), the biracial journalist who resigned from The Kenosha (Wis.) News over the headline of an article about a rally protesting the police shooting of Jacob Blake, who is Black, “said he has heard from journalists across the country who can relate to the position he was in and are proud of him for speaking up,” Rory Linnane wrote Wednesday for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
“ ‘What happened at The Kenosha News is not an isolated case,’ he said. ‘This is happening in newsrooms everywhere.’ ”
Thompson, who identifies as Black, said the headline gave a false impression of the rally, which he attended. The rally for Blake, who was left paralyzed by the shooting on Aug. 23, included calls for unity from his father, Jacob Blake Sr., and Wisconsin’s lieutenant governor, Mandela Barnes, the article said. The headline highlighted a remark from one rally participant: ‘Kenosha speaker: “If you kill one of us, it’s time for us to kill one of yours.” ‘ “
Thompson resigned after his complaint to Bob Heisse, the executive editor, was rebuffed. The headline was later changed, however.
LaSharah S. Bunting (pictured), journalism director at the Knight Foundation, “said the challenges facing journalists of color aren’t new,” Linnane wrote.
“ ‘What you’re seeing is journalists of color feel more empowered to speak up and tell their truth, a truth that’s happened for decades,’ she said.
“Bunting said journalists of color have long taken on the unsung work of flagging problematic coverage and structural racism within newsrooms.
” ‘For many Black journalists including myself, it is an important part of our work, but news organizations and news leaders have to acknowledge that it is extra work, an extra burden being put on their journalists of color,’ Bunting said. . . .”
On Twitter, Wesley Lowery, the former Washington Post reporter who has questioned the notion of objectivity, wrote, “Choice to headline/frame a piece about an all-day rally where a dozen+ speakers called for peace and reform around a single remark from a speaker so insignificant you don’t have his name is an excellent example of the subjectivity of objective journalism.”
However, writer Jeryl Bier replied on Thursday, “If you are interested, the ‘speaker so insignificant you don’t have his name’ was the president of one of the host organizations of the rally, and I found out his name. Here’s my piece at @thedispatch.
Mary Mitchell, Chicago Sun-Times: Don’t make 17-year-old Kenosha shooter a hero (Aug. 28)
Tony Norman, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ‘The Fire Next Time’ and the vigilante next door (Aug. 28)
Student Station Manager Urged to Quit Over Tweet
“An Arizona State University journalism student is refusing to bow to pressure to resign from her job at a student-run radio station because of a pointed tweet about Jacob Blake that offended Black Lives Matter supporters,” Ray Stern reported Wednesday for Phoenix New Times.
“The decision by The Blaze station manager Linda Rae’Lee Klein to stand firm against the Blaze’s board of directors and members who want her ousted puts ASU’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communications, still recovering from a racially charged scandal earlier this summer, in the delicate position of having to choose whether to remove her or not.
“. . . The New York Post article she retweeted by Gabrielle Fonrouge states that Blake was a wanted, accused rapist and police responded that day because he’d showed up at the home of his alleged rape victim. It also provided a graphic description of the alleged sexual assault that the woman said occurred in May. According to the victim — a former girlfriend of Blake’s who said he routinely beat her up — Blake had sexually assaulted her with his finger and declared that he smelled the presence of another man.”
More Prisons Blocking Media From Access
“In many cases, prison authorities have responded to increased scrutiny by making it more difficult for the press to illuminate the conditions and policies that have made more than two million incarcerated people so susceptible” to the spread of the COVID-10 virus, Karina Piser and Marcia Brown reported Monday for the American Prospect.
“Inmates have faced harsh disciplinary action for speaking to the media. But as cellmates die around them, many feel it’s worth the risk to inform the public of what’s taking place behind bars.
“According to the Marshall Project, at least 102,494 people had tested positive for COVID-19 inside prison by August 18, and at least 889 incarcerated people had died. According to the ACLU, 1,000 incarcerated people and staff have died from the disease as of August 26. Advocates say official data on infections and deaths likely represent a serious undercount due to testing shortages and checkered reporting. . . .”
- Hannah Giorgis, The Atlantic: What Incarcerated Rappers Can Teach America
- Jack Herrera, Columbia Journalism Review: San Quentin tells its own COVID story (Aug. 28)
The Elections Committee of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists announces certified candidates by video on Monday. (Credit: YouTube)
Lopez, San Martin Vie for NAHJ Presidency
Two candidates — Nancy San Martin, managing editor of El Nuevo Herald and current vice president/print of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists,, and Nora Lopez, metro editor of the San Antonio Express-News — are vying for the presidency of NAHJ in the first contest for the top post since 2012.
All told, seven of 10 positions are contested, Elections Committee members said in a video and in an online statement.
San Martin and Lopez were on opposite sides of the recent controversy over the board’s decision to delay this year’s election because of the “unpredictability” caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. The board, which included San Martin, eventually relented and agreed to an all-electronic election.
Online voting starts Sept. 28, with a virtual candidates forum Sept. 10. NAHJ announced the candidates on Monday.
San Martin (pictured) writes, “I’ve always thought of NAHJ as the equalizer for Latino journalists, providing continuous training, creating networking opportunities and building a community of storytellers whose words, images and broadcasts contribute to the tapestry of history.
“I am running for NAHJ president because I want to help open even more spaces for young journalists, mid-career and veterans who are ready to take on leadership roles. This is where we have the most impact. As an industry, we’ve got a grueling road ahead. But NAHJ is stronger than ever. . . .”
Lopez (pictured) writes, “I’ve been a part of this group for more than two decades because I’m passionate about its mission: to improve diversity in America’s newsrooms and to identify and support the next generation of Latinx journalists through scholarships and mentorship programs.”
She adds, “My goals are centered around four key issues”: transparency, advocacy, training and a comprehensive review of the bylaws, an issue that arose during the election-postponement debate. “It is key that our members know what we are doing as a board and an organization. I will make it a priority to ensure all NAHJ business is open for members and the public to see. Additionally, we should conduct open meetings via video conferencing. All members are welcome.”
The last contested presidential race took place in 2012, when Hugo Balta defeated Russell Contreras. Subsequent presidents — Mekahlo Medina in 2014, Brandon Benavides in 2016 and Balta in 2018 — ran unopposed.
Joy Reid Phrase About Muslims Creates Tempest
Executives at NBC met with members of the Council on American-Islamic Relations Wednesday amid a tempest created Tuesday after MSNBC host Joy Reid used the phrase “the way Muslims act.”
In a segment of “The ReidOut” on Monday, Reid said, “Leaders, let’s say in the Muslim world, talk a lot of violent talk and encourage their supporters to be willing to commit violence, including on their own bodies, in order to win against whoever they decide is the enemy.
“We in the U.S. media describe that as they are radicalizing those people — particularly when they’re radicalizing young people. That’s how we talk about the way Muslims act. When you see what Donald Trump is doing, is that any different from what we describe as radicalizing people?”
“Her comments came in response to President Trump retweeting a video of a pro-Trump caravan that included a man who shot paintballs at protesters.
As AlJazeera reported, “While the comments initially did not receive much attention, they were heightened after it was widely shared on social media.”
Reps. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., and Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich., among others, called on Reid to apologize. “Words matter,” Tlaib said ,”and these words feed into the harmful anti-Muslim rhetoric & actions that we continue to see in this country. It is even more painful to hear it from someone I admire. We deserve an apology. “
Reid returned to the subject on Tuesday with an 11-minute segment on how Muslims were stereotyped. Her guests were the same as on Monday. Dalia Mogahed of the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding said, “What we want though is simply objective fair coverage of all communities, of all acts of violence … and what we often see, however, is that term ‘terrorist’ is only used against Muslims. No matter what their motivation might be.”
Erik Wemple wrote Thursday for the Washington Post, “Thirty seconds would have done the trick. Joy Reid, the MSNBC host who offensively characterized the Muslim world on Monday night, could have faced the camera and regretted the way she’d framed the matter. Then she could have moved on.
“Instead of such a graceful dispatch, however, the episode on Wednesday’s edition of ‘The ReidOut’ received the cable-news version of ‘The Twilight Zone.’ Two guests came on to discuss Reid’s missteps, and the host — in the best tradition of Bill O’Reilly — displayed her mastery of the almost-apology. ‘I guess the way that I framed it obviously did not work,’ said Reid. . . “
The Council on American-Islamic Relations confirmed on Twitter the meeting Wednesday afternoon, thanking the network in a tweet for hearing its concerns, but maintaining its demand that Reid apologize for her remarks, Emily Jacobs reported for the New York Post.
“Thank you @NBC for meeting to discuss our concerns about @JoyAnnReid’s inaccurate, offensive remarks. We appreciate your pledge to avoid Islamophobia in all forms,” the organization wrote on the social media platform.
An MSNBC spokesperson told Journal-isms Thursday, “We don’t have any further comment [other] than Joy’s comments and the segment last night.”
Short Takes
- “On today’s front page, a story that gave me more hope than many I’ve reported recently,” the Washington Post’s Hannah Natanson tweeted on Friday. “Teens across America are teaming up to ask that more Black history, & more Black authors, be taught in their classrooms. ‘We have to start at the base,‘ one told me.’ “
- “NPR and Member stations in Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana are building a new model of regional news collaboration and have hired award-winning public radio journalist Priska Neely (pictured) to lead their joint Gulf States Newsroom,” NPR announced Thursday. “Neely will build a team of regional beat reporters who cover health care, criminal justice, economic justice and more. Through the Gulf States Newsroom, the stations and NPR are sharing resources, planning together and delivering more reporting in areas with widening gaps in local news coverage. . . .”
- “CBS Sports will devote five hours of programming Sunday to examining racism in sports,” Joe Reedy reported Monday for the Associated Press. “The block of programming titled ‘Portraits in Black’ will examine seminal events from the past as well as current events, including the response by athletes following the shooting of Jacob Blake in Wisconsin.” James Brown will host.
- Mary McLeod Bethune (pictured) is no longer allowed to say “Negro.” The Palm Beach Post is paying tribute to Bethune, the educator and adviser to President Franklin D. Roosevelt. Bethune will have a statue in the National Statuary Hall in the U.S. Capitol as a representative of Florida. Hers will replace that of Confederate Gen. Edmund Kirby Smith. Gov. Ron DeSantis asked that the switch be made. In reprinting one of Bethune’s speeches, the Post wrote, “Dr. Bethune used the term ‘Negro’ throughout this document, as was the custom of the 1950s. That word has been changed to Black in most references.” Editors did not respond to an inquiry about whether they would also change the “Negro” references in historic speeches by Frederick Douglass or Martin Luther King Jr.
- In July, “fifty-nine episodes of the public-affairs magazine show ‘Black Journal’ became available to stream, for the first time, as part of the American Archive of Public Broadcasting,” Doreen St. Félix reported Aug. 24 for The New Yorker. “Running, in more or less its original iteration, from 1968 to 1977, ‘Black Journal’ was a news program ‘about Blacks and for Blacks’ — one that abandoned the euphemistic notion of the ‘Black community,’ restoring to the people a sense of their variety. The virtue we call soul — ‘Black Journal’ embodied it. . . .”
- “Vanessa Díaz, an assistant professor of Chicana/o and Latina/o studies at Loyola Marymount University, offers an alternative analysis of paparazzi’s role in the Hollywood industrial complex in her new book, ‘Manufacturing Celebrity: Latino Paparazzi and Women Reporters in Hollywood, ‘ ” Gwen Aviles wrote Monday for NBC News. “Díaz argues that it’s racialized and gendered labor that fuels the celebrity news industry. The mostly Latino paparazzi and the mostly white female celebrity reporters grapple with the fallout, which includes precarious situations as well as possible violence and exploitation. . . .”
- “Emmett Till’s home on the South Side was granted preliminary landmark status Thursday — on the same date that the teen’s historic open-casket funeral was held 65 years ago,” Maudlyne Ihejirika reported for the Chicago Sun-Times. The Sun-Times editorial board supported that status. “Till was lynched on Aug. 28, 1955, while visiting relatives in Money, Mississippi, following some kind of alleged verbal interaction with a white woman, Carolyn Bryant, in a store she owned. The details of the exchange, if it occurred at all, remain sketchy to this day. . . . Landmark status would further honor Emmett and Mamie Till’s tragic but critical role in 20th century America. And given that the building has fallen into disrepair, landmarking would help protect the two-flat from demolition or ham-fisted renovation attempts. . . .”
- Peter Goldman, who met Malcolm X in 1962 when he worked for the St. Louis Globe-Democrat and was later national affairs writer for Newsweek, was dogged in his determination to find out who killed Malcolm. He messaged Journal-isms on Friday, weighing in on the Netflix series in February that claimed to uncover new evidence. Goldman wrote, in part, ” I don’t know if you’ve seen the third edition of Death & Life, but it lays out my conclusion as to who killed Malcolm X: a ‘special squad’ from the NOI [Nation of Islam] mosques in Newark and Paterson, NJ, acting on orders from Elijah Muhammad and relayed by his son, Elijah Jr., known within the Nation as E-Two. . . ” Goldman’s complete message has been added to the February Journal-isms column.
-
. . . Meanwhile, the New Yorker has excerpted the long-awaited book on Malcolm X by the late Newsday columnist and editor Les Payne, now due for publication on Oct. 20. Author Peter Eisner, Payne’s friend and former Newsday colleague, tells Journal-isms, “it nails down the day of the murder vividly as never before and with the uncompromising reporting that characterized his life work.”
- Justin M. Madden (pictured), a desk editor for the Associated Press in New York, has been named senior editor / general manager of the Sun News in Myrtle Beach, S.C., the news operation announced Thursday. “Madden will oversee the day-to-day operations of The Sun News and myrtlebeachonline.com. He arrives at a time when The Sun News is expanding its local reporting team, recently adding two new reporting positions to increase its coverage of Horry and Georgetown counties. . . .”
- Marlon A. Walker (pictured), until recently the vice president/print of the National Association of Black Journalists, has left the Atlanta Journal-Constitution after five years to become investigative and politics editor of the Clarion Ledger in Jackson, Miss. That is the No. 2 job in the newsroom, Editor Mary Irby-Jones said in a staff announcement. “Marlon will help our team continue to deliver important investigative and enterprise journalism through a statewide lens while serving our local communities. In his role, Marlon will coach reporters to make strategic coverage decisions and champion investigative and First Amendment journalism that resonates with readers,” Irby-Jones, who also edits the Hattiesburg (Miss.) American, wrote. NABJ President Dorothy Tucker Monday named Kathy Chaney, deputy managing editor of breaking news and staff development for the Chicago Sun-Times, to be vice president/print.
- “Luma Partners produces the Lumascape . . . a document that maps out firms in the ad-tech field by categorizing them by specialty and orienting them in a logical relation to one another,” Robert Klara wrote Thursday for Adweek. “. . . If you’re working in media, marketing or tech these days, the Lumascape has become the proverbial roadmap you stash in the glove compartment. Going on the reasoning that one useful way of helping the Black community is by supporting Black-owned businesses, Kawaja decided to create a new Lumascape to identify those very firms. The result is the aptly named Black Lumascape, which debuts today. . . .”
- Gustavo Arellano, who joined the Los Angeles Times in 2018 after about a decade as editor and publisher of OC Weekly, “is our newest California columnist,” Editor Norman Pearlstine announced Aug. 18. “Arellano will have a wide berth in both what he writes about and the forms he takes, but a central mission will be diving deeply into Southern California’s disparate communities and how the Latino experience is transforming the region. . . .”
- The South Asian Journalists Association is sponsoring an “Allyship Roundtable” Tuesday at 7 p.m. EDT, in which panelists “will talk about why allyship is important, how we can be better allies to each other, strategies, and struggles in 2020.” Included are “representatives from the Asian American Journalists Association (Julia Chan), National Association of Hispanic Journalists (Yoli Martinez), the National Association of Black Journalists and Investigative Reporters and Editors (Kat Stafford), as well our own Board members Mihir Zaveri and Farnoush Amiri!” See this page for free registration.
““After about 33 years covering the Chinese community for the World Journal in San Francisco, reporter Portia Li (pictured, by Kaitlin Bancroft) was laid off in April,” Nicholas Chan reported Monday for the San Francisco Examiner. “Instead of calling it quits or searching for another staff reporting job, Li is striking out on her own and putting funds from her savings into a new, locally-owned and produced newspaper. Li hopes that her weekly bilingual publication, the Wind Newspaper, can bring news about San Francisco’s Chinese community not only to Chinese locals, but also to everyone who can read and speak English. The first print issue is available this week beginning Tuesday in Chinatown. . . .”
- “Johann Calhoun (pictured) will be our first-ever Chalkbeat Philadelphia bureau chief,” the education publication announced. “Johann starts Sept. 8, joining our senior reporter and longtime Philadelphia education journalist Dale Mezzacappa, plus Cara Fitzpatrick as story editor, to form a truly powerhouse team. Johann brings the entrepreneurial spirit that we look for in bureau chiefs — a proactive doer mentality — plus deep experience in daily journalism and community engagement. He has spent the past 15 years at The Philadelphia Tribune in various senior editorial roles, and did tours of duty at the Courier Post (NJ), Bucks County Courier Times, and other newspapers. . . . [He also] has served in leadership positions with the Philadelphia Association of Black Journalists and National Association of Black Journalists. . . .”
- “Crowds drove away FOX 5 from the scene Wednesday night, preventing coverage of the protests that erupted following the shooting of 18-year-old Deon Kay in Southeast,” WTTG-TV in Washington, D.C., known as FOX5, reported Thursday. The station also said, “More than 100 people gathered outside the 7th District police station in Southeast D.C. Organizers also issued a call for additional protests on Thursday morning, which ended up at Mayor Muriel Bowser’s home. . . .FOX 5’s Evan Lambert and his crew were driven out by angry crowds claiming unfair coverage shortly after they arrived. . . .”
- CNBC has tapped KHOU Executive News Director Sally Ramirez to be the executive producer of the cable network’s upcoming news show “The News With Shepard Smith.” Veronica Villafañe reported Aug. 25 for her Media Moves column. Ramirez was to leave the Houston CBS affiliate on Friday.
- “Dodai Stewart (pictured), a great editor with a passion for visual storytelling, joins the team as deputy editor for Narrative Projects,” the New York Times announced Monday. Stewart worked “on some impactful longform features: one about a surprising murder-suicide, another about how young people of color keep drowning off of Rockaway Beach…”
- Alice Su (pictured), Beijing bureau chief for the Los Angeles Times, was detained and forced to leave the region after reporting on China’s efforts to diminish Mongolian language and culture. “A Times reporter who visited the Mongol school in Hohhot was surrounded by plainclothes men who put her into a police car,” Su wrote. “They took her to the back building of a police station, where she was interrogated and separated from her belongings despite identifying herself as an accredited journalist. She was not allowed to call the U.S. Embassy; one officer grabbed her throat with both hands and pushed her into a cell. The reporter was detained for more than four hours. She was then forced to leave the region, with three government officials and a policeman accompanying her to a train and standing at the window until the train left for Beijing. . . .”
- “More than a century after it drew international headlines for exhibiting a young African man in the monkey house, the Bronx Zoo in New York has finally expressed regret,” Pamela Newkirk (pictured) reported Aug. 26 for the BBC. Newkirk, who teaches journalism at New York University, wrote about the case in “Spectacle: The Astonishing Life of Ota Benga,” published in 2015. However, David Klinghoffer reported Aug. 28 for evolutionnews.org that Newkirk wrote in her “remarkably tough and fitting commentary” that “the apology doesn’t go far enough. It fails, among other things, to acknowledge the reality of a ‘cover-up’ and ‘stonewalling’ by the Bronx Zoo and, interestingly, by the New York Times. . . .”
- “Today The Root, a G/O Media brand and one of the largest sites covering Black news, politics, culture and opinion, announced a creative partnership with HBO – a branded writing contest for emerging Black writers – inspired by HBO’s new series, Lovecraft Country,” the organizations announced Wednesday. “The contest, titled For The Love Of The Craft, offers an opportunity for emerging Black artists to lend their voice to the short fiction contest, to have their writing reviewed by expert digital editors at The Root, as well as talented television writers from HBO, and ultimately have their work featured and published on The Root. . . .”
- “In light of recent unprecedented attacks on journalists around the United States, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), in collaboration with the News Leaders Association (NLA), launched the U.S. Press Freedom Accountability Project, the groups announced Thursday. “The initiative will support reporting on press freedom violations and accountability in relation to coverage of protests against police violence. . . .”
- “After more than a month in prison, multiple court appearances, and fears of Covid-19 infection, prominent Zimbabwean journalist Hopewell Chin’ono was granted bail Wednesday,” Columbus Mavhunga reported for CNN. “Chin’ono is charged with inciting violence ahead of a planned anti-government protest — a charge his lawyers deny. He is banned from social media and is not allowed to leave the capital Harare as part of his stringent bail conditions. . . .”
- “Journalist Yassin Juma is now free to return home after testing negative to COVID-19 which he had contracted while in Ethiopia, [in] Addis Ababa police cells,” Davis Ayega reported Aug. 28 for Kenya’s CapitalFM. Juma has opted to stay in Ethiopia. Ayega also wrote, “Yassin Juma, whose real name is Collins Juma Osemo, was arrested in early July shortly after the killing of Hachalu Hundessa, a popular singer from the Oromo ethnic group, kicked off days of violence that left more than 200 people dead. His arrest caused an outcry, with Kenya sending letters of protest to Addis Ababa, after he remained in detention for two weeks after he was ordered released on bail. . . .”
Support Journal-isms
To subscribe at no cost, please send an email to journal-isms-subscribe@yahoogroups.com and say who you are.
Facebook users: “Like” “Richard Prince’s Journal-isms” on Facebook.
Follow Richard Prince on Twitter @princeeditor
Richard Prince’s Journal-isms originates from Washington. It began in print before most of us knew what the internet was, and it would like to be referred to as a “column.” Any views expressed in the column are those of the person or organization quoted and not those of any other entity. Send tips, comments and concerns to Richard Prince at journal-isms-owner@yahoogroups.com
View previous columns (after Feb. 13, 2016).
- Diversity’s Greatest Hits, 2018 (Jan. 4, 2019)
- Book Notes: Is Taking a Knee Really All That? (Dec. 20, 2018)
- Book Notes: Challenging ’45’ and Proudly Telling the Story (Dec. 18, 2018)
- Book Notes: Get Down With the Legends! (Dec. 11, 2018)
- Journalist Richard Prince w/Joe Madison (Sirius XM, April 18, 2018) (podcast)
- Richard Prince (journalist) (Wikipedia entry)
- February 2018 Podcast: Richard “Dick” Prince on the need for newsroom diversity (Gabriel Greschler, Student Press Law Center, Feb. 26, 2018)
- Diversity’s Greatest Hits, 2017 — Where Will They Take Us in the Year Ahead?
- Book Notes: Best Sellers, Uncovered Treasures, Overlooked History (Dec. 19, 2017)
- An advocate for diversity in the media is still pressing for representation, (Courtland Milloy, Washington Post, Nov. 28, 2017)
- Morgan Global Journalism Review: Journal-isms Journeys On (Aug. 31, 2017)
- Diversity’s Greatest Hits, 2016
- Book Notes: 16 Writers Dish About ‘Chelle,’ the First Lady
- Book Notes: From Coretta to Barack, and in Search of the Godfather
- Journal-isms’ Richard Prince Wants Your Ideas (FishbowlDC, Feb. 26, 2016)
- “JOURNAL-ISMS” IS LATEST TO BEAR BRUNT OF INDUSTRY’S ECONOMIC WOES (Feb. 19, 2016)
- Richard Prince with Charlayne Hunter-Gault,“PBS NewsHour,” “What stagnant diversity means for America’s newsrooms” (Dec. 15, 2015)
- Book Notes: Journalists Follow Their Passions
- Book Notes: Journalists Who Rocked Their World
- Book Notes: Hands Up! Read This!
- Book Notes: New Cosby Bio Looks Like a Best-Seller
- Journo-diversity advocate turns attention to Ezra Klein project (Erik Wemple, Washington Post, March 5, 2014)